My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 3

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Below my left collarbone, where the strap of a sleeveless shirt would sit, I have a birthmark in the shape of a crescent moon — a clean curved horn of darker skin, maybe an inch and a half long, opening toward my sternum. It isn't raised. It doesn't change. It has simply always been there, the way the whorl in my right thumbprint has always been there. My father had the same one, in the same place, facing the same way. His father had it too, by my grandmother's account, and there was a great-uncle in a tintype photograph in her hallway — a stiff young man in a uniform from the First World War — who supposedly had it as well, though the tintype, being a tintype, proved nothing except that the family liked the story.

"The Keller moon," my grandmother called it. "It skips and it lands where it wants. Your grandfather used to say it meant the boy was marked for finding things that were lost." She said this with the satisfied air of a woman repeating something she did not believe for a second and loved completely. My father, who was a quiet man and an electrician and not given to poetry, used to tap two fingers on his own chest when I was small and say, "Same moon, Davey. Don't lose it," as if it were a tool he was lending me.

Erin loved the mark the way you love a distinguishing feature on someone you've chosen — she used to trace it, absentmindedly, when we were first married and falling asleep was still an event we attended together. When Alice was born, Erin looked for it in the delivery room before she looked at almost anything else. I remember her fingers, gentle, searching the baby's small chest under the warmer lights. It wasn't there. Alice's skin was unmarked, rose and perfect, and Erin laughed at herself and said, "Skipped a generation, I guess," and kissed the place where it would have been.

Alice discovered the mark on me when she was five, in the way of children, by inventory — counting my fingers, inspecting my ears, cataloguing the Florida burn. She put one small finger flat on the crescent and said, "You have a moon." I told her what my grandmother had told me: that it ran in the family, that her grandpa had worn the same one, that it supposedly meant the boy was marked for finding things that were lost. "You're the finding-things one," she said, with great satisfaction, as if a job had been assigned and the matter closed. For a while afterward she brought me everything lost in the house — single socks, the remote, her own shoes — and laid them at my feet like tribute, and I found them owners or homes and was, in her accounting, exactly as advertised. I have been called many things since I grew up, by clients and contractors and one memorable home seller's attorney, but *the finding-things one* was the title I was proudest of. It was also, though neither of us knew it at that kitchen table, a debt coming due.

I tell you all this now because there is no honest way to tell the rest of it without the moon on the table first. It was nothing. For thirty-nine years it was nothing — a family joke, a bit of flesh shaped like a story. I have a scar through my left eyebrow from a header off a garage roof at nine and a burn on my right forearm shaped, if you squint, like Florida, and I have never once written a word about either of them. The mark mattered only the way the panel mattered: it was there, I had noticed it, and I had decided what it meant, and I was wrong on both counts in the same direction. I thought I knew what was sealed and what was open. I thought I knew what was mine.

Alice started talking about the girl in the wall sometime in March.

I want to be careful about the chronology, because afterward — and there is a great long afterward, with questions asked by kind people in quiet rooms — afterward everyone wanted the chronology, and I found I could not give it cleanly. Children say things the way weather arrives. There's no first drop you can swear to. Sometime in March, when the snow had gone the color of old newspaper and Alice had been in the small front bedroom for four months and considered it, in the solemn way of seven-year-olds, her ancestral home, she began to mention a friend.

Her name, Alice said, was Wren. She lived in the wall. She was a little bit bigger than Alice — "this much," a hand held at forehead height — and she liked apple slices and she was scared of the dark but only sometimes, and she sang, but very quietly, so the walls wouldn't tell.

Erin and I did what parents do. We smiled in the car where Alice couldn't see. We said, "Tell Wren she's welcome at dinner," and Erin, to her credit and my shame, set a fourth plate one night in April, and Alice ate Wren's portion of peas with an air of great sacrifice. Our pediatrician, at the spring checkup, used the words *vivid* and *age-appropriate* and *new house, only child, big imagination*. The school counselor, when Erin mentioned it in an email that I thought was an overreaction and have since reread a hundred times, said the same thing in longer words. An imaginary friend after a move is practically a developmental milestone. They put it in the pamphlets.

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part