My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

Chapter 9

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She was at the far end of the space, where it narrowed under the eave, and she had made herself as small as the space allowed when the panel came away — knees drawn up, back to the chimney chase, an arm across her face against the flashlight. She wore a dress that had been outgrown by somebody else and then by her: faded blue, short in the sleeves, the hem uneven, over bare legs that were all joint and shin, and her hair was long and dark and snarled into something between a braid and a mat, as if it had been braided long ago by hands that had stopped being able to finish the job. In the crook of her other arm, held against her ribs the way Alice holds her stuffed rabbit, was a tin box — a red cookie tin, the kind that comes at Christmas, dented along one side.

"Hey," I said. My voice cracked on the one syllable like a boy's. "Hey. It's okay. It's okay, we're not — Alice, stay right there, baby — hey, sweetheart, it's all right."

She lowered her arm an inch at a time. Alice said, from beside my knee, in the voice of an interpreter, "It's my daddy, Wren. I told you. He finds things," and the girl looked at Alice, and then the flashlight — Erin had clicked it wider, or my hand was shaking and widened the beam on its own — moved across her face and down, as she pushed herself upright against the chase with the tin box clutched to her chest, and the strap of that outgrown dress slipped off her left shoulder.

I saw the mark before I understood I was seeing it. Below her left collarbone, against skin that had not seen a summer in — I did not know then how long; I knew only that she was pale the way things that grow in cellars are pale — there was a crescent. A curved horn of darker skin, an inch and a half long, opening toward her sternum. I have described my own mark in this account already, and my father's, and a stiff young man in a tintype, and I do not have other words for it, because it was not similar to mine. It was mine. It was the same shape in the same place facing the same way, drawn by the same hand, and I know the difference between a resemblance and a repetition the way I know the difference between a stud wall and a bearing wall: with my whole trained body. My whole trained body went cold from the scalp down.

She was looking at me. She had Alice's gray-green eyes — my father's eyes — and a face that some buried part of me read the way you read a room you have lived in before, and her mouth opened, and what came out of it was small and rusted from disuse and absolutely clear.

"Daddy?" she said.

Behind me, in the doorway, Erin made a sound I had never heard her make in eleven years — not a scream; worse than a scream; the sound a person makes when something comes at them from inside. She had come up the last of the stairs with her phone in her hand, she'd said something about calling her brother, about wanting a light, I hadn't attended — I had attended to nothing but the panel — and she reached the landing in time to see the girl sit up out of the dark of our wall, in time to see the face and the crescent below the collarbone and to hear the word. I turned. I saw my wife's face go the color of plaster, and I saw her understand something — I did not know what; I swear to God, standing there, I did not know what she was understanding, only that it was enormous and that it was aimed at her — and her knees simply left her, and she went down on the landing in a heap of nurse's grace undone, one hand catching at the newel post and missing it, her phone skittering away across the hall floor toward the bathroom door.

"Erin!" I had the flashlight up, swinging, wild — the beam raked the ceiling, the wall, the girl flinching back into her corner with the tin box raised like a shield, Alice crying out — and I was on my knees between two impossible things, my daughter's voice in one ear shouting "Don't scare her, don't scare her, Daddy, her eyes—", my wife motionless on the landing with her hair across her face, and a child in my wall with my father's moon on her chest who had just called me by a name I had no right to hear from her. "Erin. Erin—"

I shouted it at the house, at the stairs, at the open front door far below and the whole quiet street beyond it, loud enough to tear something in my throat, with one hand reaching back into the dark of the shaft and the other reaching out toward my wife:

"Somebody call 911!"

News in the same category

My Daughter Fed Her for Weeks — I Thought She Was an Imaginary Friend

45 Part