In the hallway afterward, Beth shook my hand and then, after a second, hugged me sideways, the way professionals hug when the file has gotten too human to hold at arm's length. "She asked me this morning if the judge could send her back to the home if she answered wrong," Beth said. "I told her there were no wrong answers today. I told her today was about the grown-ups' answers."
We drove across the river to get her. Wren came out of the children's home carrying everything she owned in a grocery bag and a backpack with a broken zipper, and she stood on the steps looking at my truck like it was a question she was still deciding how to answer. Alice leaned out the back window and shouted her name, and something in Wren's face unlocked — not happiness, exactly, but the memory of happiness, the rumor of it — and she came down the steps at a run with the grocery bag banging against her legs.
"Is the wall still there?" she asked me, in the truck, before we'd even left the lot.
"The wall's still there," I said.
"Is the hole covered?"
"No," I said. "We left it open. We can talk about what to do with it. It's your—" I stopped, because I didn't know what it was. Her room. Her door. Her hiding place. Her evidence. "It's yours to say about," I said at last.
She nodded, gravely, like a party to a negotiation, and rode the whole way home looking out at the river.
Dr. Feld's office had a rug with roads on it and a shelf of figures no bigger than my thumb. At our first visit she didn't ask Wren a single question about the wall, or Peggy, or the home. She asked her what she was reading. Wren, who had been silent for the entire drive and most of the waiting room, said, "The Hobbit. Again. Peggy had it in a box." And Feld said, "Then you already know the most important thing about holes in the ground, which is that what lives in them isn't always a monster," and Wren looked at her with the startled respect of a girl who had been quoted her own book by a stranger, and the session went from there. Twice a month, the court had said. Feld told me at the door, with Wren already halfway to the truck with Alice, "She's going to test every door in your house, David. Not the locks. The promises. She'll ask for things she's sure you'll refuse, just to watch you refuse them, so she can stop hoping. When she does—answer the same way twice."
The school assessment took place in a little room off the library at Alice's elementary school, with a reading specialist named Mrs. Abernathy who had kind eyes and a stack of graded passages in plastic sleeves. Beth had arranged it. I sat outside on a chair made for a seven-year-old and listened through the door, which is the natural posture of fatherhood as far as I can tell — too big for the furniture, ear to the barrier, heart going like a drum.
Wren read the first passage without a stumble. She read the second one, and the third, and I heard Mrs. Abernathy's voice change, the way voices do when a measurement runs off the top of the instrument. "Honey, where did you learn to read like this?" And Wren, through the door, clear as a bell: "Peggy. We had books. She said a book is a door that can't be locked from the outside." By the end of the hour she had read a passage meant for children three grades ahead of her, and explained it back in her own words, and done it all in the flat, wary tone of a person completing a task set by strangers who held power over her, which is exactly what it was.
The rest of the assessment was a map of the holes. She could read like a scholar and count money and measure a board to the sixteenth of an inch — Peggy had run a household with her, and a house is a school of a kind — but she had never raised her hand, never stood in a line, never eaten in a room with thirty children in it, never heard a bell mean anything. She did not know what a fire drill was. She did not know the pledge. When Mrs. Abernathy, meaning only kindness, asked her to write about her family, Wren wrote one sentence and then sat with the pencil down and her hands folded for eleven minutes, until the specialist, who was a decent woman, quietly took the page away. The sentence said: I have a dad and a sister and a house with a wall in it.