knew that. He had always known that, I think. He had just never said it out loud to anybody
who mattered until that morning.
Alvarez came back into the room then, and she stopped the conversation. She did it clearly.
She said my father needed to stop talking about the fire until he had an attorney present. She
said it for his protection, and for the investigation's protection, and I believed her. I did not
argue with her. I did not try to get my father to say more. I sat there and watched her write in
her notebook, and I watched my father fold his hands on the table, and I watched Duke stare
at the wall, and I tried to understand what kind of morning this had become.
Eli was taken aside for the assault process. He did not argue. He did not ask for special
treatment. He did not say that what he had done was justified because of what my father had
done fifty years ago. He stood up when the officers told him to stand up, and he walked
where they told him to walk, and before he went, he turned to my father.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"I'm sorry I hit him," he said. He was looking at me when he said it, but he was talking to my
father too.
"You should be," I said.
"I know," Eli said.
Duke stood up then. "I'll come with you," he said to Eli.
"No," Eli said. "Stay."
It was a small exchange, but it stayed with me. A grandfather offering to go with his
grandson to face the consequences of what his grandson had done. A grandson telling his
grandfather to stay, because the grandfather had his own things to face in that room, and
because Eli was old enough to walk into the next room by himself.
Mack was waiting outside with the others. Mack is one of my brothers. He is not my brother
by blood, but he is my brother in the way that matters when you are standing outside a diner
in the morning and you do not know what to do next. He was leaning against his bike,
watching the door, waiting for me.
When I came out, he handed me a glass of water. I do not know where he got it. Beth must
have given it to him. It was cold, and it was plain water, and it was exactly what I needed,
even though I did not know I needed it until I had it in my hand.
"Tell me what you need," Mack said.
"I don't know," I said.
"That's an answer," Mack said.
He did not push me. He did not ask me what had happened inside. He did not try to fix it. He
just stood there with me while I drank the water, and while the police cars sat in the parking
lot, and while the morning went on being a morning even though nothing about it felt normal
anymore.
Beth came to the door. She looked tired. She looked like a woman who had been holding a
coffee pot against her apron for a very long time and was only now letting herself feel how
heavy it had been.
"I should have stepped in sooner," she said.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"You called," I said.
"After," she said.
I shook my head. "You called," I said again. "That matters."
She nodded, but I could tell she did not quite believe me. I understood that. I have felt that
way myself, after something bad has happened and you go back over it in your head and you
find all the moments where you could have done something different, and you wish you had.
Beth had done what she could. She had called the police. She had tried to keep the room
calm. She had moved us to the back room. That was not nothing. That was a lot, actually, in
a morning like that one.
I went back inside. I went back to the narrow back room with the extra chairs and the
calendar from the previous year. My father had put his cap on his lap. He was holding it with
both hands, the way he used to hold it when somebody spoke about the men who never came
home. Duke was staring at Ruth's letter. He was not reading it, exactly. He was looking at it,
at my mother's handwriting, at the name Daniel Bell written in ink that had been on paper for