while I unlocked the door, and he said, "Call," again, and I said I would, and he left. I was
grateful he had stayed. I was grateful he had not come inside. I needed to be alone in that
house for what came next.
I went to the wardrobe in my parents' bedroom. I knew where the metal cash box was. I had
seen it before, years ago, when I was a boy and I was curious about what adults kept locked
away. The key was taped beneath a dresser drawer, in the same place it had always been.
Frank had never moved it. He had never thought I would come looking for it like this.
Inside the box were deeds. Military discharge papers. Insurance policies. An envelope with
no writing on it. I opened the envelope carefully, because my hands were shaking, and inside
it was a hospital transfer form.
A child's first name. An estimated age. A note identifying the accompanying officer:
Franklin Mercer. Condition: "Smoke exposure. Superficial burn, left wrist. Repeats 'Daddy
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
coming.'"
I looked at the pale patch on the inside of my wrist. My parents had always told me I had
burned myself on a stove before I came to them. That was the story. A stove, before I came
to them. A small burn, nothing serious. I had believed it. I had looked at that pale patch a
thousand times, in the shower, at work, holding a wrench, and I had never questioned it.
Now I looked at it, and I understood. It was not a stove. It was a fire. It was Alder Street. It
was the night my first mother had pushed me toward a man on a landing, and that man had
carried me down the stairs.
Beneath the hospital form was an adoption order. A different birth date. A different history.
An affidavit saying my birth parents were deceased and no surviving relatives had been
found. It was all typed, all official-looking, all stamped. It was a lie, typed and stamped and
filed away in a metal cash box in a wardrobe, waiting for me to find it fifty years later.
"How?" I asked my father, when I called him that night. I was sitting in my parents' kitchen,
with the box open on the table in front of me, and the hospital form in my hand, and the
adoption order underneath it. My voice was flat. I did not shout. I did not cry. I just asked the
question, and I waited for him to answer it.
"The chief knew a man who handled placements," Frank said. "There were private
arrangements. Less scrutiny."
"Who signed?" I asked. I needed a name. I needed to write it down, so I would not forget it,
so I would not let it blur into the fog of everything else I had learned that day.
Frank told me the name. I wrote it down. I wrote it down in my own handwriting, on a piece
of paper from the kitchen drawer, and I put the paper in my pocket, and I have carried that
name with me ever since, even though the man is long dead and there is nothing I can do to
him now.
"Did you pay him?" I asked.
"Yes," Frank said.
"How much?" I asked.
"Eight hundred dollars," Frank said.
Eight hundred dollars. Less than I had charged a customer for a clutch replacement the
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
previous week. Less than a decent set of tires. Eight hundred dollars for a child. Eight
hundred dollars for a boy who had been carried out of a burning building and who kept
saying "Daddy coming" while a nurse tried to loosen his fingers from a policeman's uniform.
Frank's story kept slipping into passive sentences when he talked about it. "The report was
changed." "The placement was arranged." He said it like things had just happened, like
nobody had done them, like the papers had changed themselves.
I corrected him, every time. I did not let him hide.
"The report was changed," he said.
"By whom?" I asked.
"The chief had it changed," he said.
"And you?" I asked.
"I signed it," he said.
"The placement was arranged," he said.
"By whom?" I asked.
"I asked him to arrange it," he said.
I needed him to say it in the active voice. I needed him to own the verbs. He had signed. He
had asked. He had carried. He had struck the match. Those were his verbs, and I was not