What I knew about Alder Street, before that morning, was what everybody knew. A
warehouse converted into cheap apartments. A fire before dawn. Two people dead. Several
injured. A mechanic convicted after police found a fuel can near the rear entrance. The
mechanic was Daniel Bell. I did not know that name that morning, not as a real person's
name. I knew "the mechanic" the way you know a character in a town story. I did not know
he was Duke. I did not know he had spent thirty-one years in prison. I did not know he had a
wife and a boy and a daughter. I did not know any of that, because nobody had ever told me,
and because I had never asked.
A tragedy the town uses to describe itself. Before the fire. After the fire. The old Alder lot. I
had heard those phrases my whole life. I had driven past the lot. I had never stopped there. I
had never thought about who had lived in that building, or what they had lost, or what it had
cost them to leave. I thought about it now, sitting in that back room with the calendar from
the previous year on the wall, and I felt ashamed of how little I had thought about it before.
Later, when Alvarez had stepped out to talk to the other officers and the room was quieter,
my father talked again. I do not know if he was supposed to. I do not know if his attorney
would have wanted him to. I know that he talked because he had been holding it in for fifty
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
years, and once he had said "I did" in front of his son and a room full of strangers, he could
not quite put it back.
He told us about the building owner. The owner wanted the tenants out. He had an
agreement to sell the building, and the sale was worth more if the building was empty. But
the families would not leave. They had nowhere else to go that they could afford. They
complained about the wiring and the heaters, and the owner complained about them, and
nothing changed, until the chief came to my father with a plan.
The chief told Frank they were going to damage an empty storage room. Just enough
damage, the chief said, for the building inspector to condemn the place. Just enough that the
tenants would have to move for the night, and then, once they were out, they would not be
let back in. It would be controlled. It would be safe. Nobody would get hurt.
"And you believed him?" I asked. I did not mean it as an accusation. I meant it as a question,
because I needed to know if my father had been a fool or something worse.
"I chose to," my father said.
That was the phrase he used. I chose to. Not I believed him. Not I was tricked. I chose to. He
was not hiding behind the chief. He was not saying he had no choice. He was saying he had
a choice, and he made it, and he had lived with it ever since.
Frank drove the chief there that night. He carried the can in. The chief poured it. Frank
struck the match. That was what he said, plainly, without dressing it up. He drove. He
carried. The chief poured. He struck the match. Four facts, in a row, like items on a list.
Then he heard somebody. He heard a voice upstairs. It was Duke's wife. She was upstairs, in
one of the apartments, with her boy. She was not supposed to be there, according to the plan.
The building was supposed to be empty, or at least the storage room was supposed to be
empty, and the tenants were supposed to be out for the night. But she was there. She was
home. And her boy was home with her.
Frank ran to the stairwell. The smoke was already there. It was thick, and it was hot, and it
was moving faster than he had expected. He could not see clearly. He could hear coughing.
He could hear a child crying. He could hear his own breathing, loud in his ears.
Daniel came through the back entrance then. He had gone to work early shift at the depot
that morning, and somebody had called down that Alder was burning, and he had come back
Ask Him Who Started the Fire