wiping hands and parts. It was clean. It smelled like laundry soap. I wiped my mouth with it,
and I held it in my hand, and I tried to breathe.
"I don't know who I am," I said.
Mack looked at me. He did not try to tell me I was being dramatic. He did not try to tell me I
was still the same man I had been that morning. He just said what was true, in the plain way
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
Mack always says true things.
"You're the man who gave my kid a job when nobody else would," he said.
I nodded. I did not know if that was enough. I did not know if a job I had given a kid was
enough to hold onto when everything else about who I was had just been pulled out from
under me. But it was something. It was a fact. It was a thing I had done, and nobody could
change the papers on that.
Duke stepped outside after a while. He stood in the doorway of the diner, looking at me,
looking at Mack, looking at the alley, as if he was not sure if he was allowed to be there.
"I can leave," he said.
"No," I said. I said it quickly, before I could think about it, before I could talk myself out of
it. "No."
"Did you know?" I asked him. I needed to know if he had known, if he had come to my shop
and sat at my table and drunk from the mug I set aside for him while knowing I was his son.
"No," Duke said.
"Eli?" I asked.
"He suspected your father had lied about the fire," Duke said. "He didn't know about you."
"Then why were you riding with us?" I asked. I meant with the club, with the men who had
come to the diner that morning. Why had Duke been there, in that room, on that morning, of
all mornings?
"Because you asked," Duke said.
A month earlier, Duke had helped rebuild an old carburetor in my shop. It was a fiddly job,
the kind that takes patience, and he had the patience for it. I had invited him to breakfast.
Mack had picked him up that morning, because Duke did not have a bike of his own just
then, and because that is what we do. We pick each other up. We invite each other to
breakfast.
An invitation to breakfast had brought a father within six feet of the son he had spent fifty
years mourning. That was the thought that sat in my chest as I stood in the alley with a shop
rag in my hand. Not a grand plan. Not a conspiracy. Just breakfast. Just a carburetor. Just a
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
man who was good with his hands and who needed a ride.
"How do we know?" I asked. I was not asking about the papers. I was asking about the truth.
How do we know any of this is real, and not just another story people want to believe
because it is easier than the story they have been living with?
"We don't yet," Duke said.
It was the first time that morning someone had refused to pretend that belief was proof. I was
grateful for that, too. I needed somebody to say we do not know yet. I needed somebody to
be honest about how much we did not know, even when the knowing felt like it was already
crushing me.
Frank left in Mack's truck. Mack drove him. I did not drive him. I could not, that morning. I
watched them go from the parking lot, and my father stood by the truck for a moment before
he got in, with his cap in both hands, holding it the way he held it when he was thinking
about something hard.
"I know what you must think," he said to me.
"No," I said. "You don't."
I meant that. He did not know what I thought. I did not know what I thought, not yet. I knew
I was angry. I knew I was sick. I knew I loved him. I knew I was furious at him. I knew all
of those things at the same time, and none of them cancelled the others out, and that was the
hardest part.
"Did Mom know?" I asked.
My father looked away. He looked at the parking lot, at the street, at anywhere but me.
"From the beginning?" I asked.
"No," he said.