do not send is not telling the truth. It is rehearsing telling the truth. It is making yourself feel
like you have done something when you have done nothing at all.
"After a while, I told myself the damage was done," Frank said.
"To whom?" I asked.
He could not answer. He tried, I think. He opened his mouth, and then he closed it, and the
silence on the phone was the answer. The damage was done to whom? To Duke, who spent
thirty-one years in prison for a fire he did not start? To Rose, who grew up without her
brother? To Samuel, who grew up as Ray, believing his parents were dead in a car accident?
To Ruth, who died believing her husband would tell the truth? He could not pick one,
because the damage had been done to all of us, and he had told himself it was done, as if that
meant it was finished, as if done meant over, when really it meant it was still happening,
every day, in every life it had touched.
"Did you threaten her?" I asked. I meant Ruth. I meant when she found the papers and went
to a lawyer, did he threaten her to make her stop?
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"No," Frank said.
"Don't lie to me now," I said.
"I begged her," Frank said. "For what?" I asked.
"Time," he said.
"She didn't have any," I said, and I heard my voice break on that, because it was true and it
was cruel and it was the simplest fact in the whole story. Ruth had found the papers six
months before she died. She had gone to a lawyer. She had asked for help. She had needed
time to find the truth, and Frank had begged her for time, and she did not have any time left
to give him.
I hung up the phone. I did not slam it down. I just set it back in its cradle, and I sat in that
kitchen, with the box open, and I listened to the wind chimes by the porch, and I thought
about my mother, and about how much she had tried to do in the time she had left, and about
how little time that had been.
The lawyer was Arthur Voss. He had died before Ruth did. His daughter Leah had taken
over part of his practice. She was the one who found the file, eleven years later, closing old
storage accounts that spring, going through boxes that had been put away and forgotten.
She found an unresolved file with Ruth's letter in it, and copies of documents, and a name:
Daniel Bell. The file had been marked preliminary inquiry, not active litigation. That was
why it had been put away. Ruth had died while open cases were being reassigned. Her father
had become ill suddenly. The file had been marked preliminary, and then it had been put in a
box, and the box had been put in storage, and storage had been forgotten, until Leah opened
it that spring.
A clerical mistake joined a deliberate crime, and the result was the same silence. Eleven
more years. Eleven years in which Duke was living with family nearby, helping at my shop,
setting aside a mug, and I did not know he was my father. Eleven years in which Rose was
raising her son Eli, and Eli was growing up believing his grandfather had been wronged, and
I did not know I had a sister. Eleven years in which Frank was going to my mother's grave
every Thursday, wearing his cap, and I did not know what he was carrying to that grave with
him.
Leah contacted the name on the file: Daniel Bell. It took time to find him. He had been
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
released under his legal name, but he used Cole in ordinary life. He had moved more than
once. He had lived in different places, with different people, trying to build a life after
thirty-one years in prison. Eventually Leah reached his stepdaughter, who passed the
message to Rose. Rose was Eli's mother. Rose was my sister.
Leah met me a few days after the diner. She brought a cardboard archive box with her. She
set it on the table in my shop office, and she opened it, and she said, "Your mother asked my
father to investigate before approaching you. She wanted facts, not suspicions."