as fast as he could. He had a red can in his hand. He had lunch in one hand, and the can in
the other. The can was kerosene. He had brought it home the night before because the heat
had gone out again, and his wife had asked him to bring something to keep the apartment
warm.
"They used that can like it explained everything," Duke said, very quietly, from across the
table.
He was right. I could see it, even then. A man running into a burning building with a fuel can
in his hand. A man seen leaving a building with a fuel can. If you did not know the rest of
the story, if you did not know about the chief and the match and the storage room, that can
explained everything. It was simple. It was neat. It was wrong.
I thought about the chief that night, after Alvarez had stopped the conversation and the
officers had taken Eli aside and the back room had gone quiet. I had never met the chief. He
had died with a commendation hanging in his family's living room, a man honoured for his
service, a man whose name was on a plaque somewhere, a man whose family probably still
told stories about him at holidays. I wondered what stories they told. I wondered if they
knew what he had done, or if they believed the commendation, the way I had believed the
story about a car accident, the way a family believes what it needs to believe to keep living
with itself. I did not hate the chief's family. I did not even know them. I just thought about
how a commendation can hang on a wall for fifty years, and how a lie can hang on a wall
beside it, invisible, until somebody takes it down and looks at what is behind it.
Frank had been young then. Younger than Eli is now, or close to it. A young patrolman, with
a young wife, with a nursery painted twice, with a small yellow blanket in a drawer, with
losses rarely discussed. The chief had come to him with a plan, and the plan had sounded
controlled, and safe, and small — damage an empty storage room, just enough for an
inspector to condemn the place, tenants moved for the night. It had sounded like a thing a
policeman might do to help a building owner and help tenants at the same time, a shortcut, a
favour, a way to get things done without all the paperwork. Frank had chosen to believe it,
because believing it was easier than asking what would happen if the fire was not controlled,
if the smoke was faster than expected, if somebody was upstairs who was not supposed to be
there.
I thought about the match. Frank struck the match. Those were his words, plain, without
dressing. He did not say the match was struck. He said he struck it. I kept coming back to
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
that verb, to the smallness of it, a match, a flame, a moment, and to the largeness of what
followed it — smoke, and a stairwell, and a woman behind a door, and a boy, and thirty-one
years, and a hospital form, and eight hundred dollars, and a cedar chest with a shoe in it. A
match is a small thing to hold in your hand. It is a terrible thing to hold in your memory for
fifty years.
The chief told Frank afterward what he had seen. That was the phrase my father used. The
chief told him what he had seen. Not what had happened. What he had seen, or what he said
he had seen, which was Daniel setting the fire.
If Frank told it any other way, the chief said, both of them would go to prison, and the
department would make sure Ruth never saw a pension. That was the threat. Not just prison
for Frank. Not just disgrace. Ruth would lose everything. The pension she would need if he
was gone. The house. The life they had built. The chief knew exactly where to press, and he
pressed there.
"You were afraid," I said.
"Yes," my father said.
He did not call fear innocence. He did not say, "I was afraid, so what I did was all right." He
just said yes. He was afraid. He had been afraid that night, and he had been afraid for fifty
years after, and fear had been the reason he had kept quiet, and fear did not make it right. He