stood in a courtroom, under oath, and he had said he stayed outside, when in fact he had
gone inside, up the stairs, to the landing, where the smoke was thick and the heat was
coming through the walls.
"She pushed him toward me," my father said. "She was behind a door. Part of the ceiling had
come down. I could reach the boy."
"Could you reach her?" Duke asked.
"I don't know," my father said.
"Could you?" Duke asked again. He was not shouting. He was not accusing. He was asking a
question he had been carrying for fifty years, and he needed an answer, even if the answer
was not a good one.
"I didn't try long enough," my father said.
That was the sentence that stayed with me. I didn't try long enough. Not I couldn't reach her.
Not the ceiling was in the way. I didn't try long enough. My father had lived with that
sentence for fifty years, and now he had said it out loud, in a diner back room, to the
husband of the woman he had not tried long enough to reach.
"I took him down the stairs," my father said.
Duke was very still. "They told me he died at the hospital," he said.
"Who told you?" my father asked.
"The chief," Duke said. "Later, the lawyer they gave me had a report. Smoke inhalation. No
family allowed to see him because of the condition of the body."
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
I felt my stomach turn. I felt the room tilt a little, the way a room tilts when you are hearing
something your body understands before your mind does.
"Where did you take my son?" Duke asked.
My father said, "To County General."
"Then where?" Duke asked.
My father looked at me, and said nothing.
The ride home from the diner that morning was the longest ride of my life, even though it
was only a few miles. I drove slowly, with both hands on the wheel, and I kept looking at the
pale patch on the inside of my wrist, at the traffic light ahead of me, at the shop sign as I
passed it, trying to anchor myself to ordinary things. The patch had always been there. I had
looked at it a thousand times while I worked, while I washed my hands, while I held a
wrench. It was just a pale patch, a little lighter than the skin around it, a little smooth. My
parents had told me it was a stove burn from before I came to them, and I had accepted that,
the way a child accepts a story about his own body from the people who love him. Now the
patch had a new history, and I did not know how to look at it without seeing smoke, and a
stairwell, and a man carrying a boy down the stairs while a ceiling came down behind a
door.
I thought about the blue door. I had remembered it since I was small, a blue door, painted,
chipped at the bottom, with a brass handle that was cold in winter. I had never known where
that door was. I had assumed it was a door from the car accident story, from a house I had
lived in before I came to Frank and Ruth, a house I could not remember clearly because I
was four. Now I wondered if the blue door was the door of the apartment on Alder Street,
the door my first mother had stood behind, the door she had pushed me through toward a
man on a landing. I wondered if I would ever know. I wondered if knowing would help, or if
it would just give a name to a memory that had been nameless for fifty years and had
survived just fine without a name.
I thought about the oranges, too. The smell of oranges inside a paper bag. That was a
memory I had carried without understanding it, a smell that came back to me sometimes in
grocery stores, in winter, when somebody opened a bag of oranges and the smell rose up and
for a second I was somewhere else, somewhere warm, somewhere safe. My mother — Ruth
— had bought oranges. She had kept them in a bowl on the kitchen table. But the smell in
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
my memory was different. It was oranges inside a paper bag, carried, close to my face, the
paper crinkling, the smell sharp and sweet. I wondered if my first mother had carried oranges