I stood there on the courthouse steps, between my two fathers, between my sister and my
nephew, and I felt the weight of all of it, and I did not try to make it lighter. I just stood
there, and I let it be heavy, because it was heavy, and pretending it was not heavy would not
have helped anybody.
That winter, Frank's case ended with a plea and a sentence that would almost certainly
encompass the rest of his life. He did not contest his role in setting the fire. He did not ask
me to speak on his behalf. He did not ask Rose to speak. He did not ask Duke to speak. He
stood in court, with his attorney beside him, and he accepted what the court decided, because
he had finally stopped arguing with the truth.
At sentencing, he read from a single sheet of paper. He read slowly, in a voice that was
steady, and then, halfway through, he set the paper down. He did not need it anymore, or he
could not bear to read the rest of it, I do not know which. What he said next, without the
paper, was the truest thing he had said in court, and maybe the truest thing he had ever said
to anybody.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"I have spent a long time listing the good things I did afterward," he said. "As if they could
be added up against this. They cannot."
He was right. The good things he did afterward — raising me, loving me, going to my
mother's grave every Thursday, tying wind chimes together in storms — those things were
real. They mattered. But they could not be added up against setting a fire that killed two
people and sent an innocent man to prison for thirty-one years and took a boy from his
family. You cannot do arithmetic with a life like that. The good does not cancel the bad. The
bad does not erase the good. They sit together, like Duke had said about gratitude and anger,
and you have to live with both of them.
I was there when the deputies led him out. That was all I could give. I did not speak for him.
I did not speak against him. I just sat there, and I watched him walk out of the courtroom
with the deputies on either side of him, and I thought about the man who had taught me to
ride a bicycle, and the man who had struck a match in a storage room on Alder Street, and I
understood, finally, that they were the same man, and that understanding did not make it
easier, it just made it true.
Snow began to fall outside the courthouse as we left. It was light snow, the kind that melts as
soon as it hits the ground, but it was snow, and it was winter, and it felt fitting, in a way I
cannot quite explain, that the sky was doing something quiet and cold while we walked
down those steps.
The snow was still falling when we came out of the courthouse, light, the kind that melts as
soon as it hits the ground, but it was falling, and it was cold, and the steps were slick, and we
walked down them carefully, holding onto the rail, holding onto each other, the way people
walk down courthouse steps when they have just heard a judge say words that change a life
but do not restore it. Rose held Duke's arm. Eli walked behind us, quiet, his hands in his
pockets. Leah walked beside us, carrying her folder, her face tired but steady, the face of a
woman who has done her job and knows the job is not finished, even when a hearing is over.
I thought about Frank, inside, with his attorney, waiting for his own proceedings to go on,
separate from Duke's, slower, heavier, with a sentence that would almost certainly
encompass the rest of his life. I thought about the single sheet of paper he had read from at
sentencing, and about how he had set it down halfway through, and about what he had said
without it — that he had spent a long time listing the good things he did afterward, as if they
could be added up against this, and they cannot. I thought about how true that was, and how
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
hard it must have been to say it in front of a courtroom, in front of his son, in front of the