man he had wronged, and in front of the daughter of the man he had wronged, who had said,
plainly, "I needed my brother."
I thought about Duke's wife, my first mother, and about the grave Leah had said Duke could
take the order to. I had never visited that grave. I did not know where it was, not then. I
wondered what it looked like, whether it had a marker, whether somebody had kept it clean,
whether Duke had visited it over the years, alone, without telling anybody, standing there
with a folder in his hand, or without a folder, just standing there, talking to a woman who
had pushed their son toward a man on a landing and had not come down the stairs herself. I
wondered if I would go there, someday, with Duke and Rose, and what I would say if I did,
and whether saying anything would help, or whether standing there quietly would be
enough.
Duke was waiting for me on the courthouse steps. He was standing a little apart from the
others, with his hands in his pockets, looking at the snow. When I came out, he turned to me,
and he said, very quietly, "You don't have to feel one thing."
I looked at him. I did not know what to say. I had spent months trying to feel one thing —
anger, or forgiveness, or grief, or love — and I had failed every time, because I felt all of
them at once, and I thought that meant I was doing it wrong.
"How can that be the same man?" I asked him. I meant Frank. How could the man who
taught me to ride a bicycle be the same man who started a fire and lied at a trial and paid
eight hundred dollars for a child?
"People don't always divide themselves into the pieces we'd find easiest to understand,"
Duke said.
I nodded. I understood what he meant, even if I did not like it. People are not divided into
good pieces and bad pieces, with a clean line between them. They are whole, and the whole
includes the terrible things and the tender things, and you cannot cut out the part you do not
like and keep only the part you do.
"Do you hate him?" I asked Duke. I had asked Eli that question, or Eli had asked me, and
now I was asking Duke, because I needed to know how a man who had spent thirty-one
years in prison for a fire he did not start felt about the man who had helped put him there.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"Some mornings," Duke said.
"And the others?" I asked.
"The others, I'm busy," Duke said.
I almost laughed at that, standing on the courthouse steps in the snow, with Frank being led
away inside and Rose waiting by the car and Eli standing quietly nearby. Some mornings he
hated Frank. The other mornings, he was busy. Busy living. Busy working on bikes. Busy
being a grandfather. Busy being a father to a son he had just found. That was the most honest
answer I had heard in seven months, and it was also the most hopeful, because it meant hate
was not the whole story. It was just one morning, sometimes, and then the next morning you
got up and you did the work in front of you.
We drove home in the snow, slowly, carefully, the way you drive when the roads are slick
and you do not want to make a mistake. Rose drove. Duke sat in the passenger seat. Eli sat in
the back with me. Nobody talked much. We did not need to. We had said what needed to be
said in court, and on the steps, and now we just needed to get home.
Winter passed slowly. I went to work. Duke came to the shop. Rose called. Eli came by
sometimes, with lunch, or with a question about a bike, or just to sit in the office for a while
and not talk about anything important. Frank wrote to me from where he was being held. His
letters were short. He did not ask for forgiveness. He did not ask me to visit, although I did
visit, once, in the winter, and we sat across from each other at a table, and we drank weak
coffee from paper cups, and we talked about the shop, and about the weather, and about