a headline to be true, and that a headline can make the truth smaller, not bigger, by cutting it
down to fit a space it was never meant to fit in.
I visited Frank four weeks after the diner. It was the first time I had seen him since the
morning Mack drove him away in his truck. I had talked to him on the phone. I had heard his
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
voice. But I had not seen his face, and I had not sat across a table from him, and I needed to
do that, even though I did not know what I would say when I got there.
He had lost weight. His cheek had healed. The red handprint was gone. That disturbed me
more than I expected it to. I had been carrying that mark in my mind for four weeks, as a
reminder of what Eli had done, and as a reminder of what Frank had done, and now it was
gone, and his face looked like his face again, just older, just thinner, and I did not know what
to do with the absence of the mark.
We had coffee. He made it the way he always made it, weak, in the same pot he had used for
years. We sat at his kitchen table, in the house that smelled of furniture polish and weak
coffee, and we did not talk about the fire at first. We talked about the shop. We talked about
the weather. We talked about ordinary things, because ordinary things were the only safe
ground we had left to stand on together.
Then I said, "The test came back."
"I thought it would," Frank said.
"Rose remembers me," I said.
"Don't tell me what it must be," he said. He said it quietly, but firmly. He did not want me to
tell him what it must feel like to remember a sister, or to find a family, or to learn who you
are at fifty-four. He knew he did not get to narrate that part. That part was mine.
"Did you hate the motorcycle because of him?" I asked. I meant Daniel. I meant Duke. I had
been thinking about it for weeks, about Frank's anger at my motorcycle, about the way he
had always seemed to dislike the bike, the noise, the club, the life I had chosen.
Frank nodded. "Daniel worked on them," he said.
"You thought I'd turn into him," I said.
"I was afraid you already had," Frank said.
I sat with that for a moment. Frank had been afraid I would turn into Daniel Bell, the man he
had helped convict, the man he had taken a son from. He had been afraid that the boy he had
taken would grow up to be like the man he had stolen him from, as if that would be a
punishment, as if that would prove something. He had not understood, or he had not wanted
to understand, that turning into Daniel would not have been a punishment at all. Daniel was
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
a good man.
"He's a good man," I said.
"I know," Frank said.
"No," I said. "You knew." I said it because there was a difference between knowing now,
after everything had come out, and knowing then, all along, and pretending not to know.
Frank had known Daniel was a good man. He had known it the night of the fire, when
Daniel ran back into a burning building for his boy. He had known it at the trial, when he
lied. He had known it for fifty years, and he had lived with that knowing, and he had let it sit
there, unspoken, while Daniel spent thirty-one years in prison.
"Is there anything I can do?" Frank asked me, after a long silence. He asked it like a man
who genuinely wanted to know, and who was afraid the answer would be no, there was
nothing he could do, nothing that would fix any of it.
"Yes," I said.
He looked up at me, hopeful, and I held his gaze, because what I was about to say was not
easy, and I needed him to hear all of it.
"Keep telling the truth when it stops making you feel relieved," I said. "When the lawyers
explain what it could cost you. When people stop calling. When you want to talk about
everything good you did afterward. Keep telling it."
"I will," he said.