"No," Eli said.
"So you're my uncle," he said after a moment, and he said it like a man trying out a word that
did not quite fit in his mouth yet.
"Apparently," I said.
"That's strange," he said.
"You should try my side," I said, and for the first time in three days, I almost smiled. Not
because anything was funny. Just because the strangeness of it was so large that there was
nothing else to do with it except name it out loud.
Eli stood in my shop for a while after he brought the sandwich, looking at the bikes on the
lifts, looking at the tools on the wall, looking at the photograph of Ruth on the wall in my
office. He was twenty-four, and he was my nephew, and he was also a young man who had
made a terrible mistake in a diner, and he was trying to figure out how to live with that
mistake without letting it become the whole of who he was. I understood that trying, because
I was trying to do the same thing with Frank, and with myself, and with the story I had been
told about who I was.
He told me about his grandmother, about the papers she kept, about the trial transcripts and
the letters and the newspaper clippings, about how she had helped with appeals before she
married Duke, about how she had believed him when nobody else did, or when very few
people did. He told me about growing up hearing stories about a grandfather who had been
in prison, and about how other kids at school had talked about it, and about how he had
learned to be proud of his grandfather anyway, because his grandmother had taught him that
a conviction is not the same as the truth, and that a man can be innocent even when a court
says he is guilty.
He told me about the picture online, the veterans' breakfast, Frank in his corner booth,
wearing his cap. He had seen it late at night, scrolling, and he had felt his blood rise, and he
had decided, in that moment, that he was going to go to the diner and ask Frank about the
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
letter, about the fire, about his grandmother's photograph. He had not planned to hit
anybody. He had planned to ask a question, the way I had planned to ask a question that
morning — why is my father's cap on the floor? — and his question had turned into
something else, too, the way questions do when they are asked in a room full of anger and
grief and fifty years of waiting.
"Do you hate him?" Eli asked me. He meant Frank. He was standing in my shop, with the
paper bag on my workbench, and he was asking me the question everybody would ask me in
the weeks that followed, in different ways, with different tones, but always the same
question underneath. Do you hate him now?
"I don't know how to stop loving somebody on command," I said. "But I'm learning that love
doesn't get to decide what the evidence says."
That was the truest thing I had said since the diner. I loved Frank. I had loved him for fifty
years. I could not stop loving him because I had learned something terrible about him. Love
does not work like a switch. But love also does not get to decide what the evidence says. The
evidence said Frank had struck a match. The evidence said Frank had lied at trial. The
evidence said Frank had taken a boy from a hospital and paid eight hundred dollars to
change his papers. Love did not change any of that. Love just sat next to it, uncomfortable,
and refused to leave the room.
Eli left the sandwich and went home. I ate it standing up in the shop, the way I always eat
lunch when I remember to eat it. It was a decent sandwich. I do not remember what was in it.
I remember that a young man who was my nephew had brought it to me because Mack had
told him I forget lunch, and that felt like a family thing, even though we were still learning
how to be a family, and even though the man who had made us a family in the first place had
done it by breaking another family apart.
The DNA test was done that week. Swabs, forms, signatures, all the ordinary procedures that