letting somebody else take care of her for a change. She ate her pancakes, and she drank her
coffee, and she looked at Duke, and at Eli, and at me, and her face was softer than I had seen
it since the day she walked into my old room and told me she had drawn a star on my shoe.
Halfway through breakfast, Duke took off his gloves. He wore them often. His hands were
badly burned in the fire, and cold weather made damaged skin ache, and gloves helped, even
in spring, even indoors, even when nobody else was wearing gloves. He took the right glove
off first, then the left, and he set them down beside his plate, and he picked up his fork with
his bare hands.
Along the base of his thumb, the skin formed a pale, crooked ridge. It was a scar, old, from
the fire, from reaching, from trying to get through a door, from trying to get to a boy on a
landing. I had seen his hands before, in the shop, when we worked together, but I had never
looked at them closely, not like this, not in a diner, over pancakes, with my sister across
from me and my nephew beside me.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
Something flashed through me then. Smoke. A doorway. A hand coming toward mine. Not a
complete memory. Not enough to swear to in court. Not enough to write down as a fact. But
enough to make my breath catch, enough to make my hand shake a little around my coffee
cup, enough to make me understand, in a way I had not understood before, that I had been
there, in that building, on that night, and that a hand had reached for me, and that I had
reached back.
"You went back," I said to Duke. I did not ask it as a question. I said it as a fact, because I
knew it was a fact, even if I could not prove it with a document.
"Yes," Duke said.
"For me," I said.
"Yes," Duke said.
Frank had carried me out. Duke had tried to reach me. The official story had called one a
rescuer and the other the reason rescue was necessary. That story had been wrong, for fifty
years, and now, sitting in a diner over pancakes, with a scarred hand on the table between us,
I understood how wrong it had been.
I reached across the table and took Duke's scarred hand in mine. His hand was warm. His
skin was rough where the scar was, smooth where it was not. He did not pull away. He held
my hand, and he looked at me, and Rose looked at us, and Eli looked at us, and Beth was at
the counter, pouring coffee, not watching us, just letting us have the moment.
And for the first time, with no document in front of me and no one asking me to decide what
a word should mean, I said it.
"Dad."
Duke's face crumpled. He bowed his head over our joined hands. He did not speak. He did
not need to. I had called him Dad, and he had heard it, and that was enough, for that
morning, in that diner, over pancakes that were getting cold while we held hands across the
table.
Beth came back to our table after a while, with the coffee pot in her hand. She refilled our
cups, the way she always does, without asking, because she knows who drinks coffee and
who does not, and she knows when a table needs a refill and when it needs to be left alone.
She stood there for a moment, looking at our joined hands, looking at Duke's bowed head,
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
looking at Rose, who was wiping her eyes with a napkin and trying not to make a fuss about
it.
"How's your father?" Beth asked me.
I knew which father she meant. She did not mean Duke, sitting across from me, holding my
hand. She meant Frank. She meant the old man in the corner booth, the man whose cap had
been on the floor that morning, the man who had said "I did" in front of a room full of
strangers. She meant Frank, who was now where he was, serving a sentence that would
almost certainly encompass the rest of his life.
"So far, he's managing," I said.