Frank had been furious. I remembered his face, red, his voice loud, his hands on his hips,
standing in the doorway of the garage, asking me what I thought I was doing. I had thought
he was angry at the money I had wasted, at the time I would waste, at the noise and the
people and the life I was choosing. I had not understood, then, that he was looking at a
motorcycle he recognized, a motorcycle that belonged to a man he had helped send to prison,
a motorcycle that had been seized after an arrest and sold off and passed through several
owners before ending up in that salvage yard, waiting for his son — the son he had taken —
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
to walk past it and not walk past it.
I thought about Ruth, standing beside that motorcycle in the photograph on the wall in my
office, smiling, her hand on the seat, proud, I think, of the boy who had rebuilt it, of the man
he was becoming, of the work he had done with his own hands. I thought about Frank,
standing far back, out of the frame, unable to stand close to it, unable to smile for a
photograph beside a thing that reminded him, every day, of what he had done. I thought
about how much Frank must have lived with, in that garage, watching me polish a dent he
remembered, watching me trace a weld he had seen made, watching me love a motorcycle
that was never really his to hate.
Beneath a dust cover in the back of the shop stands that motorcycle, even now. It has stood
there for years. I never sold it. It was the first one I rebuilt. It was the one Ruth stood beside
in the photograph on the wall. It was the bike I learned on, the bike I made mistakes on, the
bike I kept when I could have sold it for a decent price and bought something newer and
faster and easier.
I pulled away the cover that afternoon, after Rose left the photograph with me. I stood there,
in the back of the shop, with the dust in the air, and I looked at the tank, and at the dent near
the front seam, and at the small welded repair on the frame beneath the seat, and I felt my
hands shake, just a little, the way they had shaken in the diner that morning, when I picked
up my father's cap from the floor.
Rose put a hand to her mouth when she saw it. She had followed me to the back of the shop,
quietly, without saying anything, and she stood beside me, looking at the motorcycle,
looking at the photograph in her hand, looking back at the motorcycle, and understanding,
the way I was understanding, what we were looking at.
It was Duke's motorcycle. It was my father's motorcycle. It was the motorcycle from the
photograph, the one Duke had ridden, the one my mother had stood beside, the one I had
stood between my father's knees in front of, when I was three years old and I called every
bird a chicken and I hated peas and I liked fire engines.
I did not say anything for a long time. I just stood there, with the dust cover in my hand, and
Rose stood beside me, and the shop was quiet, except for the hum of the lights and the tick
of a clock on the wall, and the motorcycle sat there, waiting, the way it had waited for years,
for somebody to recognize it for what it was.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
Rose stayed in the shop that afternoon, after she showed me the photograph, and we sat in
the office with the photograph on the desk between us, and we talked, quietly, about the
aunt's attic, about the box she had been sorting, about the other things in the box — old
clothes, a broken lamp, a stack of magazines tied with string, ordinary things, the things
people keep in attics because they cannot quite throw them away. The photograph had been
at the bottom of the box, under a folded blanket, as if somebody had put it there to keep it
safe, or to hide it, or both. Rose had found it, and she had known, immediately, what it was,
and she had brought it to me in a plastic sleeve, holding it with both hands, because she
knew it would change something, even if she did not know what it would change.