"When?" I asked.
"Near the end," he said.
"She found the papers?" I asked.
"Yes," he said.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"And she went to a lawyer," I said.
"Yes," he said.
"What did you do?" I asked.
"I told her I would tell you," he said.
"But you didn't," I said.
"No," he said.
"Did she die believing you would?" I asked. I asked it quietly, because I already knew the
answer, and I did not want to hear it, and I needed to hear it anyway.
My father closed his eyes. He did not answer with words. He just closed his eyes, and that
was an answer.
"I loved you," he said after a moment.
"I know," I said.
"That's what makes this worse," I said, and I meant it. If he had not loved me, it would have
been simpler. I could have hated him cleanly. But he had loved me, and I had loved him, and
that love did not excuse what he had done, and it did not erase it, and it made everything
harder, because I could not just cut him out of my life like a bad part. He was my father. He
had also taken me from my father. Both of those things were true at the same time.
Mack waited until the truck pulled away, and then he turned to me. He did not say anything
wise. He just said, "Call," and he meant it, and I nodded, and then I got in my own truck and
I drove to my parents' house.
I drove to my parents' house without really deciding to drive there. My hands turned the
wheel, my foot pressed the pedal, and the truck went where it had gone a thousand times
before, to the driveway with the wind chimes by the porch. I parked, and I sat in the truck for
a while, with the engine off, listening to the chimes. They were my mother's chimes. She had
hung them by the porch years ago, and Frank had tied them together in storms, loop by loop,
so they would not break, so they would not be lost. I had watched him do it once, standing
on a chair in the rain, his hands patient, his face concentrated, as if tying wind chimes were
the most important job in the world. I had thought it was a small kindness, a husband taking
care of his wife's things. Now I thought about all the small kindnesses Frank had done, year
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
after year, and I wondered if they were kindnesses, or if they were penance, or if they were
both, and if a man can do a kind thing for a guilty reason and have it still count as kind.
The porch steps creaked the way they always had. The key was where it had always been.
The door opened, and the house smelled the way it always had, and for a moment I was a
boy coming home from school, dropping my bag by the door, calling out for my mother,
hearing her answer from the kitchen. Then the moment passed, and I was fifty-four, and my
mother had been dead for eleven years, and my father had just told me he had taken me from
another family, and the house was just a house, with furniture polish and weak coffee in the
air, waiting for me to do what I had come to do.
It was eleven years since my mother had died, and the house had been Frank's house for all
of those eleven years, but I had never stopped thinking of it as theirs. Their house. My
parents' house. The house where I grew up. The house with my mother's wind chimes by the
porch, the ones Frank tied together in storms so they would not break, the ones that still
chimed a little when the wind came through, even after all these years.
The kitchen still smelled of furniture polish and weak coffee. That was my mother's smell, or
Frank's attempt to keep her smell alive after she was gone. I stood in the kitchen for a
moment, and I listened to the house, and the house did not say anything back. It just smelled
like polish and weak coffee, and it waited for me to do whatever I had come there to do.
Mack stayed until I arrived. He followed me in his own truck, and he stood in the driveway