did not make a ceremony of it. We just agreed, in my old room, with the cedar chest open,
that we would find out, together, and that we would accept what the test said, even if it was
not what we hoped.
That night, after Duke and Rose had gone, I stayed in the house for a while longer. I put the
green sweater back in the grocery bag. I put the shoe back in. I put the rabbit back in,
carefully, so its repaired ear would not catch on anything. I closed the cedar chest, but I did
not lock it. I left it closed, and I went home, and I tried to sleep, and I did not sleep very
well.
I kept thinking about the test, and about what it would mean if it came back the way we
expected, and about what it would mean if it did not. I kept thinking about Samuel, three
years old, who liked fire engines and hated peas, and about Ray, fifty-four years old, who
ran a motorcycle repair shop and belonged to the Hells Angels. I kept thinking about
whether those two people could be the same person, and about how strange it was that I had
lived fifty years as one of them without knowing about the other.
Eli came to my shop three days later. Mack had told him I forget lunch, which is true. I do
forget lunch, most days, when I am working on a bike and the work is going well and the
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
time slips away from me. Eli brought a paper bag with a sandwich in it, and he set it down
on my workbench, and he stood there for a moment, not sure what to do with his hands.
"I'm sorry," he said.
"You said that," I said. I was not trying to be harsh. I was just stating a fact. He had said it in
the diner, in front of the police. He had said it before he was taken aside. I had heard him say
it.
"I need to say it when there aren't police standing there," Eli said.
I put down the wrench I was holding. I wiped my hands on a rag. I looked at him. He was
twenty-four. He was my nephew, although I had only just learned that word applied to him.
He was also the young man who had hit my father in a diner and left a red handprint under
his eye.
He told me how he had found where Frank ate. There was a picture online, from a veterans'
breakfast. Frank was in the picture, sitting in his corner booth, wearing his cap. Eli had seen
it, and he had gone to the diner to ask about the letter, about his grandmother's papers, about
the fire. He had gone to ask, not to fight. That was what he said, and I believed him, because
his face said it was true even before his words did.
Frank had told him to sit down. Eli had shown him his grandmother's photograph. Frank had
turned it over, face down on the table. Eli had thought Frank was dismissing her, like a piece
of paper he could put facedown and forget about. He had thought Frank was treating his
grandmother like she did not matter.
"I wanted everyone to see him," Eli said. "Then I did the one thing that made everybody look
at me instead."
I understood that. I understood the impulse to make a room look at the man you believe has
done wrong, and I understood how quickly that impulse can turn into something you regret.
Eli had wanted justice for his grandfather. He had wanted Frank to answer for the fire.
Instead, he had hit an old man in a diner, and now the story people would tell about that
morning would start with the hit, not with the fire.
"Your grandfather spent thirty-one years having somebody else decide what kind of man he
was," I said to him. "Don't hand strangers an easy lie about him."
Eli nodded. He understood. He was not stupid. He was young, and he was angry, and he had
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
made a terrible mistake, but he was not stupid.
"I'm dealing with the charge," he said. "I'm not asking him to fix it."
"Did you really not know?" I asked him. I meant about me. About Samuel. About the boy
who had been taken.