leather, feeling the stitching, feeling the wear where a rider sits, year after year. He did not
say anything for a while. He just touched the motorcycle, the way a man touches a thing he
has not touched in fifty years, gently, carefully, as if it might disappear if he pressed too
hard.
Rose stood beside me, watching him. She was crying, quietly, without making a sound, the
way people cry when they are happy and sad at the same time and they do not want to
interrupt a moment by making a noise. I put my arm around her shoulders, and she leaned
into me, just a little, and we watched our father touch his motorcycle.
I understood then, fully, what Frank had lived beside. He had changed my name, changed
my birthday, hid my father, but when I was barely grown I had gone out into the world and
unknowingly brought a piece of my first home back to Frank's garage. Frank had lived with
that motorcycle in his garage for years. He had watched me rebuild it. He had watched me
polish it. He had watched me argue with him about it. He had watched me love it, without
knowing why I loved it, without knowing that I loved it because it was my father's, because
it was a piece of home I had been taken from, because it was the one thing that had found its
way back to me, even when everything else had been hidden.
It was cruel, in a way I had not understood before. Not cruel in the way a man is cruel on
purpose, by hitting someone or lying in court, but cruel in the way life is cruel sometimes, by
bringing a thing back to you, every day, and not letting you say what it is, and not letting you
fix it, and making you live beside it, knowing what you did, and knowing that the boy you
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
took is polishing the dent you remember, in your garage, under your roof.
Duke looked up at me then, and he smiled, just a little, a sad smile, but a real one.
"You kept it," he said again, as if he still could not quite believe it.
"I kept it," I said.
Duke examined the work I had done on the motorcycle. He walked around it slowly, looking
at the engine, looking at the chain, looking at the brakes, looking at the wiring, the way a
mechanic looks at another mechanic's work, not to judge, but to understand how the man
thinks, how he solves problems, how he cares for a machine.
He pointed out two mistakes immediately. He did not do it unkindly. He did not do it to
show off. He just pointed, with a finger, at a bolt that was not quite tight enough, and at a
wire that was routed the wrong way, and he said, "That one, and that one," in a plain voice,
the way a father points out a mistake to a son who is learning, because that is what fathers
do, when they are allowed to.
I laughed. I laughed out loud, in the back of my shop, with my sister beside me and my
father in front of me, pointing out two mistakes on a motorcycle I had rebuilt when I was
eighteen and kept for thirty-six years. I laughed because it was funny, and because it was
true, and because it was so ordinary, so normal, so much like what a father and a son do
together in a garage, that I could not help laughing, even though my eyes were wet, even
though Rose was crying, even though the motorcycle had been seized after an arrest and sold
off and passed through several owners before ending up in a salvage yard.
Duke laughed too, a little. It was a short laugh, a surprised laugh, like a man who has not
laughed in a long time and has forgotten how good it feels. Rose laughed too, through her
tears, and for a moment, in the back of my shop, with afternoon light stretching across the
open garage floor, we were not a case, or a story, or a headline, or a video. We were just a
family, in a garage, looking at a motorcycle, laughing about two mistakes.
I thought about Frank then, for a moment, not with anger, not with forgiveness, just with a
kind of sadness, because Frank would never have this moment. Frank would never stand in a