years before any of us walked into that diner.
I asked again, because I had to. Because the question had been sitting in my chest since Eli
first laid those papers on the table.
"What child?"
My father closed his eyes.
Duke said it very softly, so softly I almost did not hear him.
"My son."
I listened to Duke talk about his boy, and I tried to hold the details in my mind the way you
hold small, precious things in your hands, carefully, so you do not drop them. Three years
old. Liked fire engines. Hated peas. Called every bird a chicken because nobody had
convinced him that pigeons deserved their own word. Those were not the details of a case
file. Those were the details of a child, a real child, who had lived, and laughed, and eaten,
and played, and who had a sister, and a mother, and a father, and a home, before a fire took
two of those things away and a lie took the rest.
I thought about Rose, six years old, sleeping at an aunt's house that night. I thought about
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
how arbitrary survival can be, how a child lives because she happened to be sleeping in a
different house, on a different night, for a reason nobody remembers anymore, a visit, a
sleepover, a favour, an ordinary decision that turned out to be the difference between living
and dying. I thought about how Rose must have carried that arbitrariness with her for fifty
years, the guilt of surviving, the grief of losing, the wondering why her, why not him, why
that night, why that house. I thought about how she had grown up, and become a mother
herself, and raised Eli, and kept her grandfather's papers, and passed Leah's message along,
all while carrying that night with her, quietly, the way people carry the hardest nights of their
lives.
I thought about Duke's wife, in the front room, at the window, trying to get it open, with a
neighbour watching from outside, unable to help. I tried to picture her face, her hands on the
window, her breath in the smoke, her boy beside her, crying, or quiet, or asking for his
father, saying "Daddy coming," the way the hospital form said he had said it, over and over,
even after he was carried down the stairs, even after he was taken to County General, even
after the man who carried him became the man who took him. I thought about what it must
have felt like, to push your son toward a man on a landing, to trust a stranger in a uniform
with the most precious thing you have, because there is no other choice, because the ceiling
has come down behind a door, because the smoke is too thick, because you cannot reach him
yourself.
Duke's boy was three years old. His name was Samuel. He liked fire engines. He hated peas.
He called every bird a chicken because nobody had convinced him that pigeons deserved
their own word. That was what Duke told me, in that back room, in a voice that sounded like
a man remembering a child he had not been allowed to remember out loud for fifty years.
Samuel had a sister. Her name was Rose. She was six. She was sleeping at an aunt's house
that night. That was why she was alive. Not because anybody had planned it. Not because
anybody had been clever. Just because she happened to be sleeping at an aunt's house that
night, and Samuel happened to be home with his mother.
"My wife got him into the front room," Duke said. "A neighbor saw her at the window. She
couldn't get it open."
I tried to picture it. A woman in a burning apartment, holding a three-year-old boy, trying to
get a window open while smoke filled the room. A neighbor outside, watching, unable to
help. A front room that was supposed to be safe and was not safe at all.
19
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
My father spoke then. He did not look at me. He looked at Duke.
"I reached the landing," he said.
"You never said that," Duke said.
"No," my father said.
"At the trial, you said you stayed outside," Duke said.
"I lied," my father said.
It was that simple. At the trial, my father had said he stayed outside. He had lied. He had