I believed her. That sounded like my mother. Ruth Mercer did not act on suspicion. She
acted on facts. She wanted to know the truth before she brought it to me, because she knew
the truth would change everything, and she did not want to change everything on a guess.
Leah handed me an envelope. It was addressed to me. My name was written across the front
— not the hospital name, not Samuel, not the name on the transfer form. The name my
mother gave me. Ray. Just Ray, in her handwriting, the R leaning forward, the t's crossed so
firmly the ink had torn the paper a little in one place.
I took the envelope, and I held it for a moment before I opened it. I did not want to open it in
front of Leah. I did not want to open it in the shop. I wanted to be alone with my mother's
words, the way you want to be alone with a letter that was written for you and only you.
Leah left the envelope with me, and I carried it out to my truck, and I sat there with it on my
lap for a long time before I opened it. The envelope was plain, white, a little yellowed at the
edges. My name was written across the front in my mother's handwriting, the R leaning
forward, the t's crossed so firmly the ink had torn the paper a little in one place. I traced the
letters with my finger, slowly, the way you trace a name you have known your whole life
and are suddenly seeing for the first time. Ray. Just Ray. Not Samuel. Not the name on the
hospital form. The name my mother gave me, the name she had called me when she woke
me up for school, when she called me in for dinner, when she held me after a nightmare
about a man on the stairs who couldn't find me.
I thought about opening it in the shop, in front of Leah, and I was glad I had not. Some
letters are not meant to be read in front of other people, even kind people, even people who
are trying to help. Some letters need a closed door, and a quiet parking lot, and a man alone
in a truck with the engine off, holding a piece of paper that his mother wrote six months
before she died, knowing she would not be there to say these things sitting across from him.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
The parking meter ticked outside. Cars went by. A man walked a dog past my truck and did
not look in. The world went on being ordinary, and I sat there, holding my mother's last
words to me, afraid to open them and afraid not to open them, both at once, the way you are
afraid of a thing that will change you and you know it will change you and you also know
you cannot stay unchanged any longer.
I read Ruth's letter in my truck, in a parking lot, until the parking meter expired. I sat there
with the engine off, and the letter in my hands, and I read it slowly, and then I read it again,
because I did not want to miss a word.
"My darling boy," it began. "If you are reading this, then I have failed to say these things
while sitting across from you, and that hurts more than I can put on paper. I did not know
where you came from."
She wrote that she had not known. She wrote that my father had told her I had lost my
parents, that they had died in a car accident, and that she had believed him. She wrote, "I
believed him. I wanted to believe him, and I have been asking myself whether wanting
something badly can make a person careless in ways she does not recognize. That question is
mine to answer. It is not yours to carry."
I stopped there for a long time. That question is mine to answer. It is not yours to carry. My
mother had spent the last months of her life asking herself if wanting a child badly had made
her careless, and she had decided that was her question, not mine. She had not wanted me to
carry her guilt along with everything else I would have to carry.
She wrote that she had asked for help finding the truth. "Your father says he will tell you, but