I believed him when he said it. I believed him because he had already started, and because he
had kept going even when it was hard, and because I had seen him correct himself, in that
kitchen, when he slipped into passive sentences, and because I had seen him sit with the
weight of what he had done without trying to make it lighter by listing the good things he
had done since.
I left his house that afternoon, and I drove home, and I did not feel better. I did not feel
worse, either. I just felt like I had done something real, and that real things do not always
feel good when you do them. Sometimes they just feel true, and true is enough, even when it
hurts.
Duke spent more time at the shop after that. He came by cautiously, awkwardly, sometimes
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
calling before he came, sometimes just showing up. Sometimes I called him about a part I
did not need, just to have a reason to talk to him. He never corrected me for calling him
Duke. He never told stories beginning "when you were little" unless I asked him to. He
understood that I needed to go slowly, that I needed to learn who he was as a man before I
could learn who he had been as a father to a three-year-old boy.
He was good with his hands. He was patient. He was quiet, in a way that reminded me of
myself. He liked to work, and he liked to let the work speak for itself. He did not try to make
up for fifty years in a week. He just showed up, and he worked, and he let me get used to
having him around.
Duke came to the shop more often after my visit to Frank, but he came carefully, the way a
man comes to a place where he is welcome but not sure how welcome, where he is wanted
but does not want to overstay. Sometimes he called before he came, just to ask if it was a
good time, just to ask if I needed a hand with something, just to have a reason. Sometimes I
called him, about a part I did not need, about a bike I was working on that did not really need
his help, just to hear his voice, just to have him in the shop for an afternoon, working beside
me, quiet, patient, good with his hands.
He never corrected me for calling him Duke. I noticed that, and I was grateful for it, because
I did not know what else to call him yet, and Duke was a name I had used for months, a
name that felt safe, a name that did not ask me to decide what he was to me before I was
ready to decide it. He never told stories beginning "when you were little" unless I asked him
to, and I asked him, sometimes, late in the afternoon, when the work was done and we were
cleaning up, and he would tell me a small story, about a fire engine, or about peas, or about a
bird that was a chicken, and he would tell it plainly, without dressing it up, and I would
listen, and I would try to hold the story in my mind alongside the man in front of me, and to
understand that they were the same person.
He was good with the customers, too, in his quiet way. He did not talk much, but when he
did talk, people listened, because he knew what he was talking about, and because he did not
waste words. Mack liked him. The other brothers liked him. They did not know, at first, who
he was to me, and I did not tell them, not right away, because I needed time to understand it
myself before I explained it to anybody else. When I did tell Mack, he just nodded, and he
said, "That makes sense," and I did not ask him what he meant by that, because I was afraid
the answer would be something I was not ready to hear, and also because, in a way, it did
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
make sense, the way a carburetor makes sense once you have taken it apart and put it back
together and watched it run.
One afternoon, I found Duke standing beneath the photograph of Ruth on the wall in my