"My grandfather went to prison for the Alder Street fire in 6," Eli said. "Mr. Mercer
testified that he saw him leaving the building with a fuel can."
Duke was sitting across from me. He did not look at the papers. He looked at the wall.
"Thirty-one years," Duke said. His voice was flat. "I was convicted. Thirty-one years."
Eli pushed a photocopied newspaper article across the table. The headline was faded. The
paper was old. There was a photograph of a younger Frank in a patrolman's uniform,
standing straight, looking at the camera the way young policemen do when they think they
are doing the right thing. There was a smaller photo beside it, of a dark-haired man being led
past the courthouse steps. I looked at the eyes in that smaller photo, and then I looked at
Duke, and I understood. Those were Duke's eyes. Younger, darker, angrier, but the same.
"Grandma kept everything," Eli said. "Trial transcripts. Letters. Newspaper clippings. She
knew he didn't do it."
His grandmother was Duke's second wife. She had married him after he got out of prison.
She had helped with his appeals before that, back when they were not married yet, back
when she was just a woman who believed a man she knew had been wronged and was
willing to do the work to prove it. She had kept everything. That was the kind of woman she
must have been. The kind who did not throw papers away just because a case was closed.
Eli pulled out another page. It was from the daughter of an attorney who had died, clearing
archived files. At the top of the page, in handwriting I recognized immediately, was my
mother Ruth Mercer's name. The R leaned forward. The t's were crossed so firmly that the
ink sometimes tore cheap paper. I had seen that handwriting on birthday cards and grocery
lists and notes left on the kitchen counter my whole life. I knew it the way you know your
own name.
It was a copy of a letter dated six months before she died. I read it standing up, leaning over
the table in that back room, while Alvarez watched me and Duke watched the wall and my
father watched his own hands.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
"Mr. Voss, I have found something among my husband's papers that cannot be explained by
the account he has given me. I am asking you to help me establish whether a man named
Daniel Bell was wrongfully convicted in connection with the Alder Street fire. There may
also have been an unlawful placement of a child."
I stopped reading. I looked up.
"What child?" I said.
Nobody answered me right away. Alvarez looked at my father. She warned him about
speaking without an attorney. She did it properly, clearly, the way she was supposed to do.
My father nodded. "I understand," he said.
"I understand that too," I said, because I did, and because I wanted him to know I was not
going to make him say things in front of police officers that he needed a lawyer to help him
say.
But I could not let the question go. I looked at Duke. I looked at my father. I looked at the
letter with my mother's handwriting on it, and I asked it again, quieter this time.
"What child?"
I sat in that back room and tried to make sense of the papers on the table. The newspaper
article was the hardest to look at. The photograph of my father as a young patrolman was a
man I barely recognized — straight-backed, clean-shaven, his cap sitting square on his head,
his eyes looking directly at the camera with a certainty I had never seen in him as an old
man. He looked like a man who believed the world could be sorted into right and wrong and
that he was on the right side of the line. I wondered when he had stopped believing that, or if
he had ever really believed it, or if he had just learned to wear the look the way he wore the
uniform. Beside him, the smaller photo of Duke being led past the courthouse steps showed
a man with his head down, his hands in front of him, his dark hair falling over his forehead.
He looked younger than I was when I bought my first motorcycle. He looked frightened, and
angry, and alone, all at once, and I thought about how many photographs are taken of men