or promises. We just sat there, and we talked about our mother, and about tomatoes, and
about boats that became bathtubs, and about a little boy who had called every bird a chicken.
It was not a reunion. Not yet. It was something quieter than that. It was three people
beginning to learn each other's names in a new way.
After Duke and Rose left my old room that afternoon, I sat on the floor for a long time with
the shoe in my hand and the rabbit in my lap. The room was quiet. The wind chimes were
chiming a little outside, and a car went by on the street, and a dog barked somewhere down
the block, ordinary sounds, the sounds of a neighbourhood going about its business while a
man sat on the floor of his childhood bedroom trying to understand who he was.
I thought about Rose, about the star she had drawn, about the marker her mother had told her
not to use on shoes. I thought about a six-year-old girl, trying to keep track of her little
brother with a crooked star, as if a star could keep a child from being lost, as if ink on leather
could hold a family together. It had not held us together. We had been lost anyway. But the
star had survived. The shoe had survived. The rabbit with one ear repaired in brown thread
had survived. Those small things had waited in a cedar chest for fifty years, folded in a
grocery bag, for somebody to find them and understand what they meant.
I thought about Duke, about his hands, about the way he had looked at the shoe, about the
way his voice had sounded when he said his wife made every boat a bathtub. I thought about
a man who had spent thirty-one years in prison, making birthday cards he could not send,
and then spending years after that, using a different name, moving from place to place,
trying to live a life that had been taken from him and could not be given back. I thought
about how tired he must be, and how much effort it took him to stand up from a stool in my
shop, and how he still showed up, and still worked, and still called before he came, as if he
were afraid of being a burden.
I thought about my mother Ruth, and about the letter I had read in my truck, and about the
choice she had given me. Go where the truth takes you. I had not known, when I read those
words, where the truth would take me. I still did not know, not fully. But I knew it had taken
me to this room, to this shoe, to this star, to a sister I had not known I had, and to a father I
had known as Duke, and that was farther than I had ever expected to go, and it was also just
the beginning.
We agreed to take a DNA test. It was Rose who suggested it first, I think, or maybe it was
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
Duke, or maybe it was me. I do not remember who said it first, because it did not feel like a
suggestion. It felt like the only honest thing to do next.
Not because the shoe or the memory meant nothing. They meant a great deal. The star Rose
had drawn, the song about a boat, the palm against my forehead, the smell of oranges —
those things meant something real. They were not proof in a courtroom sense, but they were
proof in a human sense, and I believed them.
But too much had already been built on what people wanted to believe. Frank had wanted to
believe he could give a boy a good home and that would make it right. The chief had wanted
people to believe a fuel can explained everything. The lawyer they gave Duke had wanted to
believe a report that said a boy had died of smoke inhalation and no family was allowed to
see him. Wanting to believe had caused enough damage already.
This time, the family would begin with the truth. Not with a hope. Not with a feeling. With a
test, done properly, with a service Leah helped us choose, one suitable for establishing the
relationship formally, so that whatever we learned next, we would know it was real.
Duke nodded when we agreed. Rose nodded. I nodded. We did not shake hands on it. We