shop office. It was a photograph I had put up years ago, of Ruth standing beside my first
motorcycle, smiling, with her hand on the seat. Duke was looking at it, very still, not
touching it, just looking.
"Are you angry at her?" he asked me, without turning around.
I thought about it. Was I angry at Ruth? She had not known, at first. She had believed Frank.
She had wanted to believe him. She had been careless, in the way she herself had written
about in her letter, in the way wanting something badly can make a person careless. But she
had also tried to find the truth, at the end, when she found the papers. She had gone to a
lawyer. She had written a letter. She had given me a choice.
"Was she kind to you?" Duke asked, when I did not answer right away.
"Yes," I said.
"Then I'm grateful for that," Duke said. He turned to look at me then. "She tried to find you,"
I said.
"I know," Duke said.
"I can be grateful she loved you and angry that I wasn't allowed to," he said. "Those things
can sit together."
That was one of the most honest things anybody had said to me since the diner. Those things
can sit together. Gratitude and anger. Love and grief. Tenderness and fury. They do not
cancel each other out. They sit together, in the same chest, in the same day, in the same man,
and you learn to live with both of them at the table.
I thought about that for a long time after Duke left that afternoon. I thought about Ruth, and
about how she had loved me, and about how she had tried, at the end, to find the truth. I
thought about Frank, and about how he had loved me, and about how he had failed, for fifty
years, to tell the truth. I thought about Duke, and about how he had been grateful and angry
at the same time, and about how that was probably the most honest way to feel about any of
this.
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
Another afternoon, Duke brought a small tin box to the shop. He set it down on my
workbench, carefully, like it was fragile, which it was, in a way. Inside were prison-made
birthday cards. Dozens of them. Crude drawings, careful lettering. Some addressed to Rose.
Others addressed to Samuel. Never sent.
"You would be ten today," one of them said, in careful handwriting, next to a drawing of a
motorcycle with wrong proportions. Inside, there was a story about a dog he had seen
through a transport van's window. He had drawn the dog, too, badly, but with love, the way a
father draws a dog for a son he cannot see.
Duke showed me the cards one by one. He did not explain them. He did not need to. Each
one was a birthday he had spent in prison, thinking about his children, making a card he
could not send, keeping it anyway, because making it was the only thing he could do.
"We've got time," I said to him, when he had shown me the last one.
He looked at me, and he looked at his hands, and I looked at his white hair, and at the effort
it took him to stand up from the workbench stool, and I knew we did not have the kind of
time we should have had. We did not have fifty years. We did not have thirty-one years. We
had some time. We had whatever time was left, and we were going to use it, even if it was
not enough, even if it never could be enough.
The seven months between the diner and the hearing felt longer than seven months. They felt
like years, compressed, with investigation meetings and phone calls and letters and waiting,
always waiting, for a court date, for a filing, for a response, for somebody to say that the
next step was ready. Leah kept me informed, in plain language, without promising more than
she could deliver. She told me when records were misplaced. She told me when a courthouse
flood had damaged part of the old file. She told me when the building owner was gone, and
when the chief had died with a commendation hanging in his family's living room. She did
not hide the hard parts from me. She did not pretend the process was fast, or easy, or fair.
She just told me what was happening, and what was not happening, and what we were