creaked in the way old houses creak, settling, sighing, as if it were tired, too. I looked at the
school drawings in the cedar chest, at the birthday cards, at Ruth's wedding dress folded
carefully on top, at the yellow blanket underneath it all. I thought about the boy who had
drawn those drawings, who had received those cards, who had slept in this room, in this bed,
with that chest at the foot of it, believing his parents had died in a car accident, believing a
stove had burned his wrist, believing his name was Ray and his birthday was in February.
That boy had grown up, and he had become a man who ran a motorcycle repair shop, and he
had become a man who was sitting on the floor of his old room holding a blue shoe with a
crooked star on it, waiting for his father to come and see it.
I thought about the green sweater, small, the cuffs worn, folded in the grocery bag. I
wondered who had knitted it, or bought it, or chosen it. I wondered if my first mother had
picked it out, or if Rose had helped pick it out, or if it had just been a sweater, ordinary,
warm, the kind of sweater a three-year-old wears in winter without thinking about it. I
thought about the stuffed rabbit, with one ear repaired in brown thread. Somebody had
repaired that ear, carefully, with brown thread, because the rabbit mattered to a small boy,
and because a repaired ear is better than a lost rabbit. I wondered who had done the
repairing. I wondered if it was my mother, sitting at a kitchen table late at night, sewing,
while I slept, while Rose slept, while Duke was at work, or at home, or somewhere else,
ordinary, before everything changed.
Duke arrived with a woman. She came in behind him, quietly, and when I stood up and saw
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
her face, I stood very still, because she had my eyes, or I had hers. It was the same look, the
same shape, the same color, and it was like looking into a mirror that had been waiting fifty
years to show me my own face.
"I'm Rose," she said.
Rose. My sister. Six years old when the fire happened. Sleeping at an aunt's house that night.
Grown up now, a mother herself, a woman who had raised Eli, who had kept her
grandfather's papers, who had passed Leah's message along, who had come to my old room
to see if the boy in the shoe was her brother.
She looked at the shoe in my hand. She looked at the star.
"I drew that star," she said. Her voice was steady, but her hands were shaking a little. "I had
a marker. Mom said I wasn't supposed to write on your shoes. I told her it was so we
wouldn't lose you."
I did not know what to say to that. I had been lost. She had tried not to lose me, with a
marker and a crooked star, and I had been lost anyway, not because of her, not because she
had not tried hard enough, but because a man had carried me out of a burning building and
then carried me away from my family, and nobody had told her where I had gone.
"What was she like?" I asked. I meant our mother. Our first mother. The woman who had
sang while she washed my hair and who had talked to the radio when the news annoyed her.
Rose smiled a little, sadly. "Funny," she said. "Impatient with people who were unkind to
waitresses. Terrible at growing anything except tomatoes."
Duke nodded. "She talked to the radio when the news annoyed her," he said.
"She sang when she washed our hair," I said. I said it before I thought about it, before I could
stop myself. It was a memory, and it was true, and it was mine, even if I had not known
whose it was until that moment.
"What did she sing?" Rose asked.
"I don't know," I said. "Something about a boat. But she changed the words."
Duke smiled, just a little. "She made every boat a bathtub," he said.
We sat in that room for a long time, the three of us, with the cedar chest open and the shoe
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
on the floor between us and the rabbit in my lap. We did not try to fill the silence with plans