like a collection of strangers who had been thrown together by a diner argument and a DNA
test, and more like people who had chosen to sit at a table together, even when it was hard,
even when the conversation was awkward, even when the silence stretched a little too long.
Spring came, slowly, the way spring always comes after a hard winter, not all at once, but in
small signs: a warmer day, a bird, a patch of ground that was not frozen anymore. Duke
wanted pancakes. That was what he said, one morning in the shop, out of nowhere, while we
were working on the Harley.
"I want pancakes," he said.
Rose was tired of cooking. She said so, plainly, when I called her. Eli had stopped looking as
if every family meal were an exam he might fail. He had relaxed, a little, in the months since
the diner, since the shop, since the court. He still carried the charge, and he still dealt with it,
but he did not carry it in his face anymore, not the way he had that first morning.
We decided to go back to the diner. Not as a ceremony. Not as a newspaper photograph. Just
as a family, going to get pancakes, because Duke wanted pancakes and Rose was tired of
cooking and Eli was hungry and I was hungry too.
Beth held the door open for us when we arrived. She smiled when she saw us, a real smile,
not a nervous one. She had been there that morning, seven months earlier, holding a coffee
pot against her apron, saying "Please, everybody stay calm." She had seen the worst moment
in that room, and now she was seeing us come back, together, for breakfast.
"Your usual?" she asked me, when we sat down.
I glanced toward the corner booth. Frank's booth. It was not Frank's booth anymore. A young
couple was sitting there now, with a toddler tearing a paper napkin into strips. The toddler
was laughing. The parents were laughing too, trying to keep the napkin pieces from getting
everywhere, failing, laughing anyway. The room had gone on living. That was what struck
me most. The room had gone on living, even after everything that had happened in it. The
booth was just a booth. The diner was just a diner. Life had kept going, in its ordinary,
stubborn way.
"Something different," I said to Beth.
She nodded, and she wrote it down, and she went to get our coffee, and I sat there with Duke
and Rose and Eli, and I felt, for the first time in a long time, like I was sitting at a table with
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
my family, not with strangers, not with a case, not with a story, just with people I knew and
who knew me.
We ordered pancakes, and coffee, and eggs, and toast, ordinary breakfast food, the kind of
food Beth had served in that diner for years, the kind of food Frank had eaten in that corner
booth, the kind of food I had eaten there with him a hundred times before. The food came,
hot, and we ate, slowly, not rushing, because there was no rush, because we had nowhere
else to be that morning, because the diner was warm, and the coffee was good, and the
company was family, even if we were still learning how to be family together.
Eli ate quietly, at first, the way he had eaten at Rose's kitchen table, the way he had sat in my
shop, careful, watching, waiting to see if he was welcome. He relaxed as the meal went on,
as Duke talked about the shop, as Rose talked about dinner, as I talked about a bike I was
working on. He laughed once, a short laugh, at something Duke said about a carburetor, and
the laugh sounded surprised, as if he had not expected to laugh in that diner, in that booth, in
that room where he had hit an old man seven months earlier. I was glad he laughed. I was
glad the room could hold a laugh, as well as a handprint, as well as a confession, as well as a
scarred hand reaching across a table.
Rose was tired, she had said so, tired of cooking, tired of carrying the weight of a family that
had been broken and was slowly, painfully, being put back together in a new shape. But she
looked less tired that morning, sitting in the diner, not cooking, letting Beth bring the food,