he worked, and he waited for me to be ready to talk.
The story reached the news. I had expected that. A story like this does not stay in a diner
back room. It travels. The short diner video traveled faster than the truth. An elderly veteran
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
struck, bikers arriving — that was the video people saw first. It was dramatic. It was simple.
It was easy to share. People filled the silence with whatever story pleased them. They did not
wait for the rest to emerge. They did not wait for the fire, or the trial, or the boy, or the eight
hundred dollars. They just saw a video, and they made up their minds.
Then the rest emerged, slowly, the way truth usually emerges, not all at once, but in pieces,
in articles, in statements, in court filings. Frank received messages calling him a monster. Eli
received messages calling him a hero. Both descriptions made everything easier for people
who weren't there. A monster is easy to hate. A hero is easy to cheer for. Neither description
was true, and neither description helped anybody understand what had actually happened in
that diner, or in that fire, fifty years ago.
The news came in waves, not all at once. First the video, short, shaky, an elderly veteran
struck, bikers arriving, a diner, a morning. People shared it because it was dramatic, because
it was simple, because it confirmed what they already believed about bikers, or about old
men, or about young men, or about diners in small towns. Then the articles, longer, with
more detail, with the fire, with the trial, with the thirty-one years, with the boy, with the
eight hundred dollars. People read those, too, but they read them more slowly, and they
shared them less, because the truth was complicated, and complicated things do not travel as
fast as simple things.
Frank received messages calling him a monster. I saw some of them, because people
forwarded them to me, or because they showed up on my phone, or because Leah told me
about them. They were cruel, and they were simple, and they made everything easier for
people who weren't there, because a monster is easy to hate, and hating a monster does not
require you to think about a young patrolman with a nursery painted twice, or about a chief
who threatened a pension, or about a man who carried a boy down a stairwell and then
carried him away. Eli received messages calling him a hero. Those were simple, too, and
they were wrong, too, because Eli had hit an old man in a diner, and hitting an old man in a
diner is not heroic, even if the old man has done terrible things, even if the young man
believed he was standing up for his grandfather.
I thought about the people who sent those messages, sitting at home, typing on their phones,
deciding, in a moment, who was a monster and who was a hero, as if a life could be sorted
that easily, as if fifty years could be reduced to a word. I did not answer them. I did not try to
correct them. I knew, by then, that correcting strangers on the internet is a waste of time, and
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
that the truth does its work slowly, in courtrooms, and in kitchens, and in shops, and in
diners, not in comment sections.
Eli gave one statement through his attorney. I read it when it was published. It was short. It
was clear. It did not make excuses.
"What I did in the diner was wrong. The investigation into the fire matters more than
anything I did."
That was all he said, publicly. He did not try to use his grandfather's story to justify hitting
my father. He did not try to make himself the hero of a story that was not his to be the hero
of. He just said what he did was wrong, and that the fire mattered more. I respected that. I
respected it a great deal, even though I was still angry at him for hitting Frank, and even
though I knew I would be angry about it for a long time.
Frank declined interviews. He did not talk to reporters. He did not try to explain himself to
the public. He talked to the investigators, and he talked to his attorney, and he talked to me,
when I would talk to him, and that was enough. He knew that anything he said to a reporter