knows something is different but he does not know what it is yet. Then he saw me, standing
beside the motorcycle with the dust cover in my hand, and he saw Rose, standing beside me,
holding the photograph, and he walked toward us slowly, the way a man walks toward
something he is afraid to believe in.
He walked toward the motorcycle slowly, one step at a time, and when he got close enough
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
to see it clearly, he stopped again. He looked at the tank. He looked at the dent near the front
seam. He looked at the small welded repair on the frame beneath the seat. He reached out,
very slowly, and he touched the damaged seam on the tank with his fingertips, the way you
touch something you thought you would never see again.
"I dropped a wrench on that," he said. His voice was very quiet. "Your mother said I treated
the thing better than the kitchen table."
I nodded. I did not say anything. I did not need to. He was remembering, out loud, in front of
me, a small, ordinary moment from a life that had been taken from him. He had dropped a
wrench on the tank. My mother had teased him about it. She had said he treated the
motorcycle better than the kitchen table. It was a joke, a small joke, between a husband and a
wife, in a kitchen, a long time ago, before a fire, before a trial, before thirty-one years in
prison.
"You kept it?" Duke asked me. He was looking at me now, not at the motorcycle. "All these
years."
"Yes," I said. "All these years."
I had kept it because it was my first motorcycle. I had kept it because I had rebuilt it with my
own hands. I had kept it because Ruth had stood beside it in a photograph. I had kept it for
all the reasons I had told myself over the years, none of which were the real reason, because
the real reason was that it was my father's motorcycle, and I had known it, somewhere
underneath all the stories I had been told, even when I did not know I knew it.
The shop was quiet that afternoon, except for the hum of the lights and the tick of the clock
and the sound of Duke's breathing, slow, steady, as he looked at the motorcycle. I had turned
the sign on the door to closed, without really thinking about it, because I did not want a
customer to walk in, not then, not in the middle of this moment. Mack was out on a job. The
other brothers were elsewhere. It was just the three of us — me, Rose, and Duke — and a
motorcycle that had waited thirty-six years in my shop, and fifty years in total, to be
recognized for what it was.
I thought about all the times I had walked past that motorcycle, under its dust cover, in the
back of the shop, and not thought about it, not really. It was just there, a part of the shop, like
the workbench, like the tools on the wall, like the photograph of Ruth on the wall in my
office. I had kept it because it was my first, because I had rebuilt it, because I was
Ask Him Who Started the Fire
sentimental about it in the way mechanics are sentimental about their first rebuilds. I had
never thought to ask where it had come from before the salvage yard, or who had owned it
before the several owners who had passed it along, or why Frank had been so furious when I
brought it home at eighteen. I had just kept it, and polished it, and argued with Frank about
it, and lived beside it, the way Frank had lived beside it, without knowing what we were
living beside.
Now I knew. Now Rose knew. Now Duke knew. The motorcycle was not just a motorcycle.
It was a piece of home, a piece of a family, a piece of a life that had been taken and then,
without anybody planning it, had found its way back. It had come back through a salvage
yard, through several owners, through eighteen years, and it had parked itself in Frank's
garage, and it had waited, patiently, for me to be ready to see it for what it was.
Duke ran a hand over the seat. He ran it slowly, from the front to the back, feeling the