previously troubled to tell us: which parts of your paper can bend. We will give our answer
tomorrow. And Captain—my uncle does not speak it, so the record-keeper will: if a shot is fired in
this valley tonight, from any side, we will know it was not an accident. Accidents have been
rationed here, like everything else. Whoever spends one will be charged its full price."
The shot, when it came that night, was not fired at a person.
Jonas told himself that afterward, in the inventory a man makes of mercies when the alternative
inventory is too red to open before breakfast. It was fired at a parfleche case, in a lodge that was
supposed to be empty, at the hour when the camp's watch changed and the moon had not yet
cleared the western rocks. But the case was not where the field book slept—nothing real slept
where it was expected to, in that valley, that week, including most of the people—and the lodge
was not empty either, because Jonas, who had taken to sleeping badly and in installments, had gone
there an hour before midnight with a lamp turned low to copy, for the third time, the parley's
minutes from Grady's sergeant's fair record, so that the band would hold its own account of the day
in its own keeping. He was sitting on the floor with the papers on a board across his knees when the
canvas at the lodge's back lifted, not as wind lifts canvas, and a man's shape came through the gap
in the posture of someone who has rehearsed an errand in darkness and means to be quick.
What happened next happened at the speed of things that are later remembered in pieces and
argued about in sequence. Jonas said, in later tellings, only that he knew the man by his hands. It
was not a figure of speech. The lamp was low and the man's face was wrapped to the eyes in a strip
of dark cloth, but as he came across the lodge floor toward the case—toward the place where a
stranger, briefed by stolen knowledge, would believe the field book lay—his left hand reached first,
and Jonas saw the ink on the fingers, ground in, three years' worth of it, a working stain no washing
day removed. And he was on his feet with the board coming up as a shield before he had finished
understanding that he had recognized Ambrose Fitch in the dark, by the hand, the way his wife had
in the sunlight, and that knowledge was the last clear thing in the night.
Fitch had a knife. He had not come to shoot anyone; the shot came from outside, afterward,
when Kito—who had been sleeping, those three nights, in the brush behind Senna's lodge with his
rifle and his grief and a blanket, a guard he had assigned himself without informing the guarded—
heard the canvas tear. Fitch used the knife the way clerks use things, without training and with total
commitment, and Jonas stopped the first pass with the board and the second with his forearm and
felt the third find the meat of his shoulder and go in to a depth that his body reported to him in a
voice of pure, clarifying information. He got both hands on Fitch's wrist. The document case man
was slight and sandy and much stronger than his silhouette, the strength of panic in a creature
caught mid-errand in the dark, and they went down together across the parfleche case, which burst,
which spilled—not the field book, never the field book, but blankets, and tallow candles, and three
years' worth of hoarded string—and Fitch's hand came free once, and Jonas put his own head,
deliberately, where a head should not be put, into the space the knife wanted, and Kito's shot came
through the lodge door then and took the lamp, whether by design or by the mercy that governs bad
aim in the dark no one ever established, and in the black and the noise and the smell of spilled oil
Fitch made the door gap and was gone, running, Jonas knew by the sound, not toward the road but
down toward the spring, toward the brush, toward the valley he had entered as baggage and meant
to leave as weather.
They did not catch him that night. Let it be said plainly, because Senna said it plainly at the fire
before dawn, when the camp had assembled itself out of the dark with rifles and lanterns and the
particular rage of people whose house has been entered: they did not catch him, and the failure was
general, and general failures in that valley were paid for in a currency of shame that no one spent
on recrimination until the work was done. Kito rode the spring brush with six men until the sky
greyed and came back with a strip of dark cloth on a thorn bush and a set of tracks that left the
water eastward, afoot, in the direction of the column's camp, and lost themselves, with a cunning
Jonas filed away for the hearing, among the horse tracks of Grady's own picket. By then Jonas was
sitting on the floor of his own lodge with his shirt cut away and his shoulder open, watching his
wife prepare to be his surgeon, and discovering that there are forms of intimacy a wedding does not