protection, to this — a door its owner opened and shut at her own choosing, whose hinges no board
had touched. On the steps she stopped. From the headquarters building behind them, as the party
crossed toward their lodging with its inside-barring door, came the sound of a pen, many pens,
already at work on the consequences.
The findings were read at noon the next day, to a fuller room — officers of the garrison, the
Gallinas marshal summoned by telegraph and still wearing the road, and Mr. Voss, who attended
because the law that made him complainant obliged him to hear what his complaint had purchased.
The board found, and the colonel read, in the voice of a man reading weather that would change
other men's climates: that the Voss Consolidated survey filing rested on readings falsely entered
and was void in its entirety, and would be certified void to the land office with the board's
recommendation that no successor filing by the same interest be received without a survey
conducted in the presence of the department; that the occupancy of the Tamarisk people in the Rio
Seco valley, and their use of Tamarisk Spring, stood confirmed by the agency's own confirmation
of September ninth, eighteen eighty-one, and that the department would maintain that occupancy in
writing, a copy of the written agreement to be furnished to the band and read aloud to it, in both
languages, by a reader of the band's choosing. That the events at Red Tanks constituted the firing,
by paid auxiliaries of a private company, upon a parley party under a flag of truce; that the names
of the fourteen dead of the Tamarisk people were entered in the record in full, furnished by Chief
Haskay, and were to be transmitted with the findings to the Department of the Interior and to the
civil authority, and here the colonel read the names, all fourteen, slowly, in a locked room become a
chapel by nothing but the reading, and Naiche's name came where Senna had placed it in her
testimony, among her people's, spelled as her sister-in-law had spelled it, and Kito stood by the wall
with his hat in his hands and his eyes dry and said nothing at all, which was his whole eulogy and
entirely sufficient. That the testimony and documents concerning Cornelius Voss, his company's
paymaster arrangements of eighteen eighty-one, the procurement of perjury and theft, the
employment of violence against a witness and of an armed errand against another, be forwarded
under seal to the United States Attorney, with Ambrose Fitch, the Gallinas assayer, and the prisoner
Breedlove remanded to civil custody, and Cornelius Voss himself bound over on his own
recognizance and that of his company's bond, in a sum the colonel named without looking up,
which made even Pruitt close his eyes.
And last, because boards, like grandmothers, keep the item that matters most to them for the end
of the tally: that Captain Walter Grady's conduct, examined entire, disclosed no act of corruption
and one act the board would characterize, at the colonel's dictation and against the major's first
draft, with unusual care — that Captain Grady, under pressure improperly brought to bear by civil
and commercial interests, had erred in judgment at the outset of this matter, had thereafter corrected
that error at the cost of his own standing with the parties applying the pressure, had protected
witnesses of every party including those he was ordered to regard as hostile, and had placed upon
the record, voluntarily and in writing, matter injurious to himself that no other witness could have
supplied. The board censured the error. The board commended the correction. The board
recommended that Captain Grady be relieved of duties touching the Rio Seco, as a man
compromised in the valley's favor — the colonel read that phrase without flinching, as Grady
himself had once read a phrase of the colonel's without flinching — and retained in the service with
his record whole. Grady stood at attention through all of it, and afterward, in the corridor, shook
hands with Haskay first, which no officer of Jonas's acquaintance had ever done in a headquarters
building in the presence of witnesses, and then with Jonas, and said, "Your wife was right about the
minutes, Hartley. Three hands. Four. Mine was the one I feared, and it turned out to be the only one
I could still read with any pleasure. Give my respects to the old lady, and tell her the colonel is lean.
It will annoy her to have been wrong, and a woman of her quality should not be allowed to rest."
The agreement was written before they left the fort, because the band had learned what
unwritten agreements were worth and the colonel, to give the devil of paperwork his due, had
learned it in the same room. It came out of the adjutant's office in fair copies: the valley confirmed,
the spring confirmed, the boundaries set by the true survey, which the department would run anew
at its own expense with the band's reader present at every station; no removal, no lease, no road
through the valley without the council's consent written and witnessed; the findings' names
appended, so that the dead traveled with the document wherever the document went, which Betsa,
hearing it read aloud on their return, pronounced the first white paper she had ever met that carried
its own ghosts honestly. The field book was retained as an exhibit by the board — with a copy,