would find the tent by following the paper smell, cousin, I swear it on—" he stopped, and what
stopped him was not Jonas's face but the veil, which had turned toward him with the slowness he
had taught the whole camp to read as warning, and Senna's voice came through it without heat and
without mercy, the voice of the family's memory speaking to the family's grief.
"Naiche," Senna said.
Kito went utterly still.
"Say her errand the night before the tanks, cousin. You have never said it in this lodge. Say it
now, into this morning, so we can all carry the same weight in the same direction."
"She carried messages," Kito said at last, hoarsely. "Between the fires. Because Reyes drank and
the old chief wanted a person the auxiliaries would not—" His voice broke, once, cleanly, like a
stick. "She carried the white flag's spare cloth. In her arms. Folded. She was carrying the flag itself,
spare, folded in her arms, when the firing started, Senna. I have never told it because when I tell it I
see the cloth. It was white for a long time afterward where it lay, because the dust—" He mastered
himself with visible effort, a man reining a horse at a cliff's edge. "Do not use her to keep my rifle
home. It is beneath you."
"I use her," Senna said, "because she is the only argument you have ever listened to, and because
she would have used herself, cousin, in a heartbeat, and did. Listen to me. If you kill Fitch in the
dark, Voss buries a clerk and buys a headline: Apache murders reach into Army camp, witness
silenced by her own band, story unfit for any board. The woman Naiche carried a flag for becomes
a paragraph under your name in a newspaper his company feeds. If Fitch lives—if he is produced,
living, at a hearing, and made to sit where I can see his hand and name it, and the paymaster's book
of eighteen eighty-one is demanded of his employer, and the names in it are read aloud by my
husband, who reads straight—then Naiche's flag is carried into the one room in this territory where
it can still stop a firing line." The veil held on him, three degrees past warning, into a country Jonas
had no map for. "I am not asking you to forgive him. I have not forgiven him. I dream in water,
Kito, three years on; do you think I ask lightly? I am asking you to let me spend him, instead of
spending yourself. He is worth more to Naiche alive and exhibited than dead and avenged. That is
the arithmetic. You taught me arithmetic like that is not cruelty. It is the count. Do the count."
The lodge was quiet for a long moment that Jonas did not measure, because measuring it would
have been a trespass.
"The count says live," Kito said finally, in the voice of a man reading a document he hates in a
language he trusts. "The count says the witness testifies and the clerk is exhibited." He picked up
his hat from where he had not remembered putting it down. "I will say the rest at the fire: that I lost
him, and that I will be part of the guard that brings him back if he runs again, and that I will not
ride east alone. And cousin—" he looked at Jonas, and for the first time since the arroyo, since the
judgment fire, since the word skeptic was invented for men like Kito, there was nothing held back
in it at all—"when we ride to wherever they hold this hearing, I ride beside your wife, and you ride
beside my uncle, and if the man with the ink on his hands is in that room, brother, you will point
him out with that shoulder before it heals crooked. Swear the reading on it."
"On the reading," Jonas said, and put out his good hand, and Kito took it, and the grip was a
treaty of the kind that outlasts paper.
The council's answer was composed before noon, and it was composed the way the band did
everything that mattered: publicly, at the fire, with Betsa cracking nuts over the minutes and Tavi,
recalled from the lookout rock under armed escort of his own importance, sitting very straight
beside the trade box as if the box's honor were in his personal charge. Jonas wrote the answer down
as Haskay dictated it, in English and Apache both, his left hand doing the writing and doing it
badly, which Senna corrected without comment, line by line, in a hand that did not waver.
The Tamarisk band accepted the board of inquiry. It accepted on conditions, which were read
into the document with the same care other men give to the loading of rifles.
The board would sit at Fort Mercer, where the colonel's authority, and not the company's
hospitality, furnished the room. Its membership would be named in writing forty-eight hours before
it sat, and any member who had eaten at Cornelius Voss's table in Gallinas in the present year
would be challenged by name. The witness would travel with an escort of her own people, under
flag the whole road, lodged apart, and guarded by soldiers of Captain Grady's own company and no
other; Grady's word as an officer, which he had laid on the parley table like a coin of known